Fishers Council Rejects One Sixteen Housing Development

The unanimous vote ends a proposed 26-lot residential project on 116th Street next to the Spyglass Hill neighborhood.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in City Hall

Wide view of an empty suburban two-lane road beside cleared land and a line of mature trees under soft overcast daylight.
The Fishers City Council unanimously rejected the One Sixteen development on 116th Street, citing traffic concerns and unmet promises to Spyglass Hill residents. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think new housing developments in your area are making traffic worse?

The Fishers City Council unanimously rejected the One Sixteen planned unit development, which proposed 26 residential lots on about 10.45 acres at 10401 E. 116th St. The Fishers Plan Commission had unanimously recommended against the project on Nov. 4.

Why it matters

Councilor Todd Zimmerman said traffic in the corridor was his primary concern and that mitigation commitments made to Spyglass neighborhoods have not been delivered, so adding residential development would not be fair to those residents. The decision shapes how Fishers balances new housing against road capacity and promises made to existing neighborhoods.

The council vote was unanimous, following a unanimous unfavorable recommendation from the Plan Commission on Nov. 4 after a public hearing. The developer's revisions added acceleration and deceleration lanes, replaced a dry detention area with a retention pond, and increased rear setbacks, but the council still rejected the project.

The players

Fishers City Council

The elected legislative body of Fishers, Indiana, which holds final authority over zoning and planned unit development approvals in the city.

Todd Zimmerman

A Fishers city councilor who identified traffic in the 116th Street corridor as his primary concern about the project.

The details

Neighboring residents raised concerns about runoff affecting water quality at Lake Stonebridge, additional traffic, and design fit at the Plan Commission hearing. The developer adjusted the design after that meeting, but the council voted against the project on Nov. 16.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 4, 2026: Plan Commission gives unanimous unfavorable recommendation.

  2. Nov. 16, 2026: City Council unanimously rejects the One Sixteen development.

  3. 2027: City plans to add a stoplight on 116th Street at Spyglass Falls.

Political Context

The rejection follows the Legends at Geist PUD zoning that currently governs the site, and it turns on whether the city will hold developers to mitigation commitments made to the adjacent Spyglass neighborhoods. Councilor Zimmerman's objection rests on those prior promises rather than on the number of homes alone.

Fishers residents along 116th Street will not see the 26-lot development built as proposed. Residents near the site should expect traffic patterns to remain as they are until the planned 2027 stoplight at Spyglass Falls is installed.

The takeaway

Local rezoning votes often hinge on promised infrastructure that must be delivered before new housing is approved. Residents who track PUD proposals can check whether earlier mitigation commitments in their neighborhood have been funded.

Further reading

Follow more local decisions in Fishers City Hall.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Current Publishing.

Live Poll

Do you think new housing developments in your area are making traffic worse?