Plan Commission Opposes One Sixteen PUD Rezone

Fishers Plan Commission unanimously recommended against a 26-lot residential development at 10401 E. 116th St.

Updated on Nov. 5, 2026 in Residential

Plan Commission Opposes One Sixteen PUD Rezone

Live Poll

Should your community approve new housing developments despite local traffic and runoff concerns?

The Fishers Plan Commission voted unanimously to send an unfavorable recommendation to the City Council on the One Sixteen PUD, a proposal for 26 residential lots on about 10.45 acres at 10401 E. 116th St. Numerous neighboring residents spoke at the public hearing and all opposed the plan.

Why it matters

Residents cited concerns about runoff affecting water quality at Lake Stonebridge and added traffic along the 116th Street corridor. The Fishers City Council will make the final decision on the rezone, which would change the site from its current Legends at Geist PUD zoning.

The proposal now includes four brownstone-style homes with rear-entry garages fronting 116th Street and 22 single-family homes, with estimated prices between $800,000 and $900,000. Whether the developer will revise the plan again before the Council vote has not been stated.

The players

Michael Mercho, Integra Builders

Michael Mercho is the developer who presented the One Sixteen PUD proposal at the public hearing, and Integra Builders is the firm behind the plan.

Fishers City Council

The Fishers City Council is the municipal legislative body that will make the final decision on the rezone request after the Plan Commission's recommendation.

The details

The plan includes a planned wet and dry water detention area and a single full-access entry/exit point from 116th Street. The site currently contains one structure, a church, and the developer, Michael Mercho of Integra Builders, presented the plan at the hearing.

Timeline

  1. July: Original One Sixteen PUD proposal introduced with 32 homes.

  2. Nov. 4: Plan Commission public hearing and unanimous unfavorable vote.

  3. Nov. 16: Fishers City Council scheduled to consider the rezone.

Market Dynamics

The proposal would replace the Legends at Geist PUD designation on the 10.45-acre parcel with a new planned unit development. The reduction from 32 to 26 lots shows the developer adjusting density after the original July proposal.

Residents near 116th Street and Lake Stonebridge face possible changes in traffic and runoff if the rezone is approved by the Council. Homebuyers interested in the planned $800,000 to $900,000 homes would need to track the Council's decision before the site's zoning is finalized.

The takeaway

Residents who want to weigh in should follow the Fishers City Council's Nov. 16 agenda, since the Council has the final say on the rezone. The Plan Commission's unanimous unfavorable vote signals significant opposition heading into that meeting.

What happens next

The Fishers City Council is scheduled to consider the One Sixteen PUD rezone at its Nov. 16 meeting.

Further reading

For more on local housing proposals, see Residential coverage in Fishers.

Live Poll

Should your community approve new housing developments despite local traffic and runoff concerns?