Indiana Landmarks Lists Ayres House, Castle Hall

Two historic Indiana properties, a Fortville estate and an Indianapolis hall, are on the preservation group's 10 Most Endangered list.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Politics

Indiana Landmarks Lists Ayres House, Castle Hall

Live Poll

Should your community prioritize saving historic buildings over redevelopment?

Indiana Landmarks has placed the Ayres House in Fortville and Castle Hall in Indianapolis on its 10 Most Endangered list. The Ayres House is being considered for several proposals, including a sale for $1.

Why it matters

The listing highlights historic properties across Indiana that the preservation group considers significant and in imminent danger of demolition or loss. For Indiana readers, the outcome of the Ayres House proposals could determine whether a landmark estate is preserved or lost for good.

The Ayres House is being offered for a proposed sale price of $1, and it is one of 10 Indiana properties on the Indiana Landmarks list. The town's final choice among the proposals has not been announced.

The players

Indiana Landmarks

Indiana Landmarks is a statewide historic preservation nonprofit that publishes an annual list of endangered properties across Indiana.

Town of Fortville

Fortville is a small town in Hancock County, Indiana, that acquired the Ayres House in 2024 and is weighing proposals for its future.

The details

The Ayres House was built in 1913 as a grand estate in Fortville for Arthur B. Ayres and his family, and it later served as a funeral home for much of the last hundred or so years. Castle Hall, built in 1911 on North Senate Avenue in Indianapolis, served as a cultural, social and economic hub for the city's Black community.

Timeline

  1. 1911: Castle Hall is built on North Senate Avenue in Indianapolis.

  2. 1913: The Ayres House is built as a grand estate in Fortville.

  3. 2024: The town of Fortville acquires the Ayres House.

  4. November 20, 2026: The 10 Most Endangered list is published.

City Hall

The annual 10 Most Endangered list from Indiana Landmarks has become a recurring tool for drawing attention to at-risk historic buildings across the state. This year's inclusion of the Ayres House and Castle Hall places two very different properties, a rural estate and an urban community hall, under the same preservation spotlight.

Residents of Fortville and Indianapolis may see changes to familiar landmarks depending on how the Ayres House and Castle Hall are handled. The Ayres House could become a bed and breakfast, a boutique, or a restaurant, and if no buyer comes forward it could be lost permanently.

The takeaway

Historic places often depend on a specific buyer or use to survive, so listings like this one can prompt owners and communities to act before a building is lost. Readers interested in local preservation can track town decisions on properties in their own area.

What happens next

Fortville officials are reviewing several proposals for the Ayres House, and a decision on its future is expected once the town selects a path forward.

Further reading

Explore more local government and civic coverage in City Hall.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Fox 59.

Live Poll

Should your community prioritize saving historic buildings over redevelopment?