Pots and Pans Pie Co. Named Among Top U.S. Pie Shops

USA TODAY included the Indianapolis bakery in a national list of the best pie shops, as it expands with a new Irvington production space.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Openings & Closings

Golden-crusted pies cooling on a wire rack beside a window with soft daylight and a brick wall, suggesting a small-batch bakery expanding production.
Pots and Pans Pie Co., an Indianapolis bakery founded by Clarissa and Ian Morley, was named among USA TODAY's best U.S. pie shops as it expands production. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

USA TODAY has included Pots and Pans Pie Co., an Indianapolis bakery at 4915 N. College Ave. in the Meridian-Kessler neighborhood, in a national lineup of the best pie shops. The shop, which opened in late 2018, is known for a sweet potato pie with toasted marshmallow topping and pecan pralines.

Why it matters

The recognition places a locally founded bakery among a nationwide set of pie shops, spanning from Palm Desert, Calif., to upstate New York. The company's purchase of a co-manufacturing space in Irvington signals a shift toward scaling production for its own pies and for other independent vendors.

Pots and Pans operates from 4915 N. College Ave. and opened in late 2018, having started as a mid-2010s farmers market operation. The extraction does not provide revenue, output volume, or the square footage of the new Irvington space.

The players

Pots and Pans Pie Co.

An Indianapolis pie bakery known for its sweet potato pie with toasted marshmallow topping and pecan pralines, which also ships frozen pies nationally and to Canada.

USA TODAY

A national daily newspaper published by Gannett that compiled the list of best pie shops in the country.

The details

Owners Clarissa and Ian Morley started Pots and Pans primarily as a farmers market operation in the mid-2010s before opening the College Avenue shop. The business distributes frozen pies nationally and in Canada through the online marketplace Goldbelly, and the Morleys have also opened a sister hot dog and soft serve concept, The Clubhouse, at the Monon Trail and 54th Street.

Timeline

  1. Mid-2010s: Pots and Pans begins as a farmers market operation.

  2. Late 2018: Pots and Pans opens at 4915 N. College Ave.

  3. 2025: The Morleys open The Clubhouse at Monon Trail and 54th Street.

  4. October 2026: Pots and Pans announces the purchase of a co-manufacturing space in Irvington.

  5. November 2026: USA TODAY names Pots and Pans among the best pie shops in the country.

Market Landscape

Pots and Pans' national frozen-pie sales through Goldbelly place a Indianapolis bakery in the same direct-to-consumer channel used by regional food producers nationwide. Its Irvington co-manufacturing purchase adds capacity that could let it produce for other independent vendors, not just its own pies.

Customers in Indianapolis and those ordering online can access Pots and Pans' pies locally or through national frozen shipping via Goldbelly. The new Irvington production space may affect future product availability, though the extraction does not state when it will begin operating.

The takeaway

A neighborhood bakery that began at farmers markets can reach national audiences by pairing local production with online marketplace distribution. Readers interested in pie can compare the shop's offerings with other top-rated bakeries on the USA TODAY list.

Further reading

Explore more Indianapolis business openings and closings to see how local food ventures are growing.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Indystar.