Appeals Court Keeps CorVel Fee Dispute Out of Arbitration

Indiana's appeals court upheld the Worker's Compensation Board's refusal to send a hospital's fee dispute with CorVel to arbitration.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Healthcare

Appeals Court Keeps CorVel Fee Dispute Out of Arbitration

The Court of Appeals of Indiana ruled on November 10, 2026, that the Worker's Compensation Board properly kept a fee dispute between CorVel-Memorial Hospital and CorVel out of arbitration. Memorial Hospital of South Bend had treated four employees of CorVel's clients, and CorVel reimbursed the hospital on the employers' behalf.

Why it matters

The ruling confirms that the Board holds exclusive jurisdiction over worker's compensation fee disputes, even where a provider agreement calls for arbitration. The dispute will return to the Board for a hearing on proper payment, affecting how providers and managed-care vendors resolve reimbursement conflicts in Indiana.

Memorial Hospital filed five fee-adjustment applications with the Board between 2022 and 2024, and CorVel's arbitration argument relied on a 1997 agreement last amended in July 2014. The merits of whether CorVel applied the statutory fee schedule correctly remain unresolved.

The players

CorVel Corporation

CorVel is a national managed-care company that administers workers' compensation networks and reimbursements for employers and their insurers.

Memorial Hospital of South Bend

Memorial Hospital is a South Bend, Indiana hospital that treated employees of CorVel's clients and filed the fee disputes with the state Worker's Compensation Board.

The details

CorVel moved to dismiss the hospital's applications and compel arbitration under American Arbitration Association rules named in a 1997 Preferred Provider Organization Hospital Agreement. A single hearing member denied the motion, and the full Board agreed it had exclusive jurisdiction; the appeals court compared CorVel's clause to a recent Indiana Supreme Court clause referencing 'then current' AAA rules and found CorVel's agreement did not include that language.

Timeline

  1. 1997: Preferred Provider Organization Hospital Agreement signed, requiring AAA arbitration for unresolved disputes.

  2. July 2014: CorVel agreement last amended.

  3. 2022 to 2024: Memorial Hospital files five fee-adjustment applications with the Board.

  4. November 10, 2026: Court of Appeals of Indiana upholds the Board's refusal to arbitrate.

Industry Dynamics

The appeals court measured CorVel's 1997-era arbitration clause against a recent Indiana Supreme Court clause that referenced 'then current' AAA rules, and found the omission decisive. The ruling reinforces the Board's exclusive role over fee disputes that the Supreme Court's contract-language line leaves intact.

Providers treating injured workers in Indiana may face reimbursement delays while fee disputes sit before the Board rather than in arbitration. Employers and their claims administrators should expect the fee-schedule question to be decided on the statute rather than on private contract terms.

The takeaway

Contract arbitration clauses do not override the Worker's Compensation Board's authority over statutory fee disputes in Indiana, so providers should check whether their agreements reference current arbitration rules.

Further reading

For more on payer-provider reimbursement fights, see Healthcare coverage across Indiana.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Human Resources Director.