Judge Dismisses Narcolepsy Discrimination Claims Against ISP
A federal magistrate judge ruled that Indiana State Police are shielded by sovereign immunity from private damages claims under the ADA.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should government agencies be immune from lawsuits over disability discrimination?
Federal Magistrate Judge Kellie Barr of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana dismissed the Americans with Disabilities Act claims brought by former paralegal Kimberly Ratliff against the Indiana State Police. Ratliff alleged she was illegally fired because of narcolepsy, that the agency failed to accommodate her condition, and that it retaliated against her for seeking an accommodation.
Why it matters
The ruling holds that the state police agency is entitled to sovereign immunity from private damages claims, which limits the ability of individuals to sue state agencies under the ADA for these types of allegations. The decision addresses the threshold immunity question rather than the merits of Ratliff's allegations.
The federal magistrate judge dismissed Ratliff's ADA claims on sovereign immunity grounds in a ruling issued Monday, November 9, 2026. Whether Ratliff will appeal the dismissal has not been reported.
The players
Indiana State Police
The state law enforcement agency of Indiana, which was the defendant in the lawsuit and is entitled to sovereign immunity from private ADA damages claims under the ruling.
Kellie Barr
A United States Magistrate Judge for the Southern District of Indiana who issued the ruling dismissing the claims.
The details
Ratliff, a former paralegal, alleged the Indiana State Police fired her illegally because of narcolepsy and failed to accommodate the condition under the Americans with Disabilities Act. She also alleged the agency retaliated against her after she sought an accommodation. The court dismissed these claims by finding that the state police are shielded by sovereign immunity from private damages suits.
Timeline
Monday, November 9, 2026: Magistrate Judge Kellie Barr issued the ruling dismissing Ratliff's ADA claims against the Indiana State Police.
Legal Context
The ruling applies the sovereign immunity doctrine that limits private damages suits against state agencies under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The decision places this employment discrimination case within that existing limit on federal court remedies against state governments.
Indiana residents who work for state agencies and need disability accommodations face a federal court precedent that limits their ability to sue for damages under the ADA. Employees should understand that remedies against state employers may be restricted by sovereign immunity.
The takeaway
Sovereign immunity can bar private damages claims against state agencies even when those claims involve federal disability rights laws, which affects how state workers can seek redress.
Further reading
For related coverage of how courts handle disability claims against state governments, see Law news.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.
Live Poll
Should government agencies be immune from lawsuits over disability discrimination?










