West Ada Board Votes to Close McMillan Elementary

Trustees unanimously decommissioned the Idaho school, which will shut at the end of the school year as enrollment has dropped sharply.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Lifestyle

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single empty one-story school building with a large playground in front, evoking the closure of a shrinking suburban elementary school.
The West Ada school board voted unanimously Monday to close McMillan Elementary at the end of the school year as enrollment has fallen 62% since 2014. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should school districts close neighborhood schools when enrollment drops significantly?

The West Ada school board voted unanimously Monday night to decommission McMillan Elementary, with students transferring to other district schools at the end of the school year. Enrollment has fallen 62% since 2014, leaving the school at 36% of its 475-student capacity.

Why it matters

The district says the building's declining use and an estimated $5.4 million in repairs needed within 10 years drove the decision. Nineteen parents, students and community members spoke against the closure at an October meeting, and a parent-organized petition has gathered 639 signatures.

Enrollment at McMillan has fallen 62% since 2014, with 171 students currently attending a building designed for 475. The district estimates $5.4 million in repairs and updates will be needed within 10 years, and the final disposition of the property remains undecided.

The players

West Ada School District

The public school district serving the West Ada area of Idaho, which operates McMillan Elementary and makes decisions about its facilities and enrollment.

David Binetti

A West Ada school board trustee who made the motion to decommission McMillan Elementary at the end of the school year.

The details

The vote followed two community input meetings in September and public comment at an October board meeting, where every speaker opposed closure. Trustee David Binetti made the motion to shut down the school at the end of the school year, and the district will work out new attendance boundaries in the coming months. The district's staff will also present a detailed proposal for the building, which may include selling or leasing it.

Timeline

  1. September: District holds two community input meetings on McMillan.

  2. October: School board hears public comment, with all speakers opposed.

  3. Monday: Board unanimously votes to decommission McMillan Elementary.

  4. End of the school year: McMillan Elementary is scheduled to close.

  5. 2031: Projected enrollment would drop to 121 if the school stayed open.

Local Context

The McMillan closure reflects the consolidation of underused elementary buildings as enrollment declines in aging facilities across the West Ada district. Like other districts facing shrinking student counts, West Ada must weigh the cost of maintaining older schools against the capacity of its remaining campuses.

Families with students at McMillan will need to transfer to other West Ada schools at the end of the school year. The district will announce new attendance boundaries in the coming months, which will determine where affected students are reassigned.

The takeaway

Enrollment declines can make older school buildings costly to maintain relative to the students they serve. Families affected by school changes should watch for the district's upcoming boundary announcements to plan transportation and enrollment.

Further reading

Explore more Primary Education coverage for context on school enrollment and facility decisions in Meridian.

Live Poll

Should school districts close neighborhood schools when enrollment drops significantly?