Iowa Supreme Court Dismisses Schultz Will Challenge
The state's high court ruled a 2024 challenge to a 2003 will came too late under Iowa's probate deadline.
Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Law

The Iowa Supreme Court dismissed a challenge to the 2003 will of Lorraine Schultz, holding that the will contest was filed nearly five years after the will was admitted to probate in January 2019. The court vacated a Court of Appeals decision and reversed a district court ruling in the case.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces that Iowa's statutory deadline for contesting a will has no tolling or equitable exception once a will is admitted to probate, a point that affects how families and heirs in Iowa pursue estate disputes. It also resolves a dispute over how a family settlement agreement interacts with a later will.
The Iowa Code section 633.309 deadline for filing a will contest was June 2019, but the plaintiffs filed in June 2024, after the will was admitted to probate on January 29, 2019. The 2003 will allocated 477.5 acres to Blaine and 107.83 acres to each daughter.
The players
Iowa Supreme Court
The state's highest court, which vacated the Court of Appeals decision and reversed the district court ruling in the Schultz will dispute.
The details
Cloy and Lorraine Schultz owned several farm properties in northeast Iowa and signed mirror image wills in 1998 splitting their remainder equally among four children. Lorraine Schultz later made a new will in July 2003 that gave Blaine most of the land, and after the daughters learned of it around 2014, the four children signed a family settlement agreement dividing the farms equally. The plaintiffs argued the 2003 will was not operative when first filed because the settlement was filed at the same time, but the court held the statutory deadline still applied.
Timeline
1998: Couple signed mirror image wills splitting the remainder equally.
July 2003: Lorraine Schultz made a new will favoring Blaine.
Around 2014: The daughters learned about the 2003 will.
July 2014: Family settlement agreement dividing the farms was signed.
January 11, 2019: Lorraine Schultz died; the 2003 will was admitted to probate January 29, 2019.
Legal Context
The decision applies Iowa Code section 633.309 as written, rejecting arguments for equitable exceptions once a will has been admitted to probate. Under this reading, heirs who miss the statutory window have limited recourse even when a later family agreement is in dispute.
Iowa residents planning estates or contesting a will should note that the state's probate deadline is strictly enforced once a will is admitted to probate. Families relying on a later settlement agreement rather than a timely contest may lose their claim to property.
The takeaway
Heirs who believe a will is invalid or superseded should act within the statutory deadline, since Iowa courts have held that the filing window is not extended by later settlement efforts. Consulting a probate attorney early can preserve options that would otherwise expire.
Further reading
Explore more in Law coverage across Iowa's courts and legal decisions.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.






