Journal Editor Warns of AI and Predatory Publishing

Environmental Health Perspectives editor Joel Kaufman spoke at a Yale roundtable on how AI and business shifts are reshaping academic publishing.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Environmental

Flat-color editorial vector illustration of plain cream folders on an oak surface beside a small pile of brass discs, evoking academic publishing economics.
Journals have received 50 percent more submissions and shifted toward article-processing charges, with editor Joel Kaufman warning of AI and predatory publishing pressures at a Yale roundtable. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust scientific research published today more than you did five years ago?

At a roundtable hosted by the Yale Center on Climate Change and Health, Environmental Health Perspectives editor-in-chief Joel Kaufman discussed AI and predatory practices in academic publishing. The roundtable drew about 20 graduate students, researchers and medical faculty.

Why it matters

Kaufman said his journal has received 50 percent more submissions than before, and it bans using AI to write peer review feedback while allowing AI in research. For New Haven, home to Yale, the discussion highlights how publishing pressures affect the scientific work produced locally.

The figures come from the journal's own editor describing rising submissions, not an independent audit. The extraction does not say how much AI-written content is currently reaching journals.

The players

Joel Kaufman

Kaufman is a University of Washington professor and editor-in-chief of Environmental Health Perspectives, a peer-reviewed journal in environmental health.

Environmental Health Perspectives

Environmental Health Perspectives is a peer-reviewed scientific journal covering environmental health research.

Yale Center on Climate Change and Health

The Yale Center on Climate Change and Health is a university research center that studies the health effects of climate change.

The details

Kaufman said journals have shifted from institutional subscriptions and print advertising toward article publishing charges over the past 10 to 15 years. He noted that the big publishing companies have higher profit margins than Google and Amazon, and that AI has increased researchers' productivity, with authors accountable for any AI-assisted final product.

Timeline

  1. 10 to 15 years ago: Journal business models began shifting toward article publishing charges.

  2. 2020: A now-withdrawn paper claimed jade amulets might prevent COVID-19.

  3. Thursday, November 19, 2026: The Yale roundtable on AI and academic publishing was held.

The Big Picture

The discussion echoes the 2020 withdrawal of a paper claiming jade amulets might prevent COVID-19, a case that exposed how weak peer review can let unsupported claims reach print. Rising submission volumes now test that same review system, which typically relies on two or three reviewers per paper.

Readers who rely on published environmental health research should note that journals are weighing AI use and rising submissions, which can affect how quickly and carefully findings reach the public. Authors remain accountable for AI-assisted work, so readers can watch for corrections and withdrawals as a signal of review quality.

The takeaway

Peer review and journal business models shape which science gets published, so checking whether a study has been corrected or withdrawn is a useful habit when reading research news.

Further reading

Explore more environmental science coverage for context on how research in this field is produced and reviewed.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Yale Daily News.

Live Poll

Do you trust scientific research published today more than you did five years ago?