Judge Trims Challenge to Colorado Gun Permit Law

A federal judge dismissed much of a suit against Senate Bill 25-3 but allowed some claims to advance to a spring jury trial.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Politics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a columned government building with a domed roof against a cream field, evoking the state's gun permit law under legal review.
A federal judge dismissed much of a lawsuit challenging Colorado's permit-to-purchase law for semiautomatic firearms but let some claims proceed to a spring jury trial. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should Colorado require a permit and training before buying most semiautomatic guns?

Federal Judge William J. Martinez partially dismissed a lawsuit by the Colorado State Shooting Association and five members challenging the state's permit-to-purchase law for most semiautomatic firearms. Martinez allowed the plaintiffs' as-applied Second Amendment claims to proceed to a jury trial.

Why it matters

The ruling narrows the legal challenge to Senate Bill 25-3 while keeping open the question of how the permit requirement applies to individual buyers in Colorado. Its outcome could shape how the state's gun purchase rules are tested in court.

Martinez dismissed all claims tied to the law's ban on rapid-fire trigger devices, ruling they are accessories rather than arms protected by the Second Amendment. The remaining as-applied claims, including one from a disabled veteran, are set for trial.

The players

William J. Martinez

A federal judge who issued the order partially dismissing the challenge to Colorado's permit-to-purchase law.

Colorado State Shooting Association

A gun rights group that joined five members in suing the state over Senate Bill 25-3.

The details

Martinez issued the ruling in an order on the state's motion to dismiss the 2025 suit. Under the program, buyers must meet objective requirements of sheriff approval, safety training and passing an exam before they can purchase covered guns.

Timeline

  1. 2025: The shooting association and five members sued the state over Senate Bill 25-3.

  2. August 2026: The law's major provisions took effect and more than 3,500 applications were submitted to sheriffs.

  3. November 18, 2026: Martinez partially dismissed the lawsuit.

  4. Spring 2027: A jury trial is scheduled on the remaining as-applied claims.

Political Context

The plaintiffs' core objection centers on wait times for required classes and potential fees, which they raised in their complaint against Senate Bill 25-3. Their remaining as-applied claims will test whether those burdens violate Second Amendment protections for individual buyers.

Gun buyers in Colorado who must meet sheriff approval, safety training and exam requirements under Senate Bill 25-3 remain subject to the permit process while the as-applied claims are pending. The ruling does not suspend the law's purchase requirements.

The takeaway

The case shows that courts can separate broad facial challenges from narrower as-applied claims, leaving individual permit burdens to be tested at trial. Buyers and gun owners should track the spring 2027 trial outcome for clarity on how the law applies in practice.

What happens next

A jury trial on the remaining as-applied claims is scheduled for spring 2027.

Further reading

For more on how courts handle these disputes, see Law coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Colorado Newsline.

Live Poll

Should Colorado require a permit and training before buying most semiautomatic guns?