Consumer Reports Flags Holiday Scams to Avoid
Fraudsters target shoppers with fake pet sales, gift card theft, and social media gift exchanges during the busy holiday season.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Financial Crime

Live Poll
Do you feel confident you can spot holiday shopping scams?
Consumer Reports has identified common holiday scams shoppers should avoid this season. Fraudulent breeders advertise pets that do not exist, while thieves steal gift card numbers before cards are sold and drain balances after activation.
Why it matters
Fraud tends to peak during the holidays because people shop, give gifts, and travel more than usual, which can make them less cautious. Recognizing these tactics early can help shoppers protect their money and personal information.
Consumer Reports and the Better Business Bureau have issued warnings about these tactics, but no specific cases, charges, or enforcement actions are detailed in the available reporting. The extent of current losses remains unquantified.
The players
Consumer Reports
Consumer Reports is a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization known for independent product testing and consumer-protection reporting.
Better Business Bureau
The Better Business Bureau is a nonprofit organization that tracks business complaints and publishes consumer fraud alerts and scam warnings.
The details
Scammers advertise pets that do not exist and demand unexpected fees, such as heated crate or transportation charges, before disappearing with the buyer's deposit. Thieves also steal gift card numbers before cards are sold and drain balances right after activation, while social media gift exchanges such as Secret Sister are pyramid schemes that can leave participants empty-handed and expose personal information.
Timeline
The holiday shopping season is the peak period for gift card scams and online shopping fraud.
Legal Context
Holiday scams such as fake pet sales and gift card theft fall under existing U.S. fraud statutes, and Consumer Reports' seasonal warnings reflect a recurring pattern of fraud rising during peak shopping periods. Pyramid-style gift exchanges like Secret Sister are treated as pyramid schemes, a category of fraud long targeted by consumer-protection enforcement.
Shoppers should be wary of pet listings that request extra fees before pickup, and should buy gift cards only from trusted sources and check their balances after purchase. Social media gift exchanges that require sending a gift to a stranger in hopes of receiving several in return should be avoided, since they can expose personal information and leave participants with nothing.
The takeaway
Sudden demands for extra charges and gift-for-gift promises are major red flags during the holidays. Verifying a seller and checking gift cards promptly can prevent most of these losses.
Further reading
For more on how fraud schemes operate, browse our Financial Crime coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by WPBF.
Live Poll
Do you feel confident you can spot holiday shopping scams?






