Water Agency Asks SFPUC to Revisit Drought Plan
Palo Alto officials discussed SFPUC drought assumptions and water rates at a joint study session that SFPUC officials did not attend.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Business

Live Poll
Do you expect your household water bill to keep rising faster than inflation?
The Palo Alto City Council and Utilities Advisory Commission held a joint study session on Monday night on drought assumptions and water rates, and SFPUC officials did not attend. Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency CEO Tom Smegal has separately asked the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission to reassess its design drought.
Why it matters
Board members sought solutions to concerns that the SFPUC's conservative drought approach is driving up rates and misleading customers about future demand. The dispute centers on how the regional wholesaler plans for drought and capital improvements, which shapes what Bay Area agencies pay for water.
The SFPUC supplies 26 agencies represented by BAWSCA, which take about two-thirds of available water, while Palo Alto residents account for less than 5% of the wholesale supply and use about 40 percent less water than 20 years ago. Whether the SFPUC will change its drought planning assumptions remains unresolved.
The players
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
The SFPUC owns the regional water system in the Bay Area and sells water wholesale to 26 member agencies, with its drought planning rules and capital improvement decisions now under scrutiny.
Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency
BAWSCA is an agency representing 26 water customers that buy wholesale supply from the SFPUC, and its CEO Tom Smegal has pressed the SFPUC to reassess its design drought.
The details
Smegal said BAWSCA's staff lacked the capacity to conduct its own study of drought effects, and Palo Alto officials said the SFPUC's approach affects customer rates. The study session was originally set for one hour and ran into a second hour, with the SFPUC absent from the discussion.
Timeline
May 2025: Stone sent a letter to the SFPUC asking it to review its assumptions.
Monday, November 16, 2026: Palo Alto City Council and Utilities Advisory Commission held the joint study session.
Market Landscape
The dispute sits inside the wholesale arrangement between the SFPUC and the 26 BAWSCA member agencies, which together depend on the SFPUC's regional system for most of their supply. How the SFPUC sets drought planning and capital assumptions determines the rate pressure carried by these wholesale customers.
Palo Alto residents are a small share of SFPUC wholesale water, so the drought assumptions at stake mainly flow through to rates paid by the agencies that buy from the regional system. Customers should watch whether the SFPUC changes its planning assumptions, since those choices feed directly into what local agencies charge for water.
The takeaway
Drought planning assumptions set by a regional wholesaler can reach household water bills across many cities at once. Readers in Palo Alto and the wider Bay Area can track future SFPUC rate and planning decisions to see how these assumptions play out.
Further reading
For related coverage of regional water and power providers, see Utilities on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Palo Alto Online.
Live Poll
Do you expect your household water bill to keep rising faster than inflation?






