Judge Awards $1.26 Million in Fees in LAFD Suit

A Los Angeles judge granted about $1.26 million in attorneys' fees to two plaintiffs who won against the Los Angeles Fire Department, well below the $12.4 million requested.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Politics

Judge Awards $1.26 Million in Fees in LAFD Suit

Live Poll

Do you trust local government to fairly handle discrimination complaints against its own workers?

Judge Michael Shultz awarded nearly $1.26 million in attorneys' fees to Sean Morris and Mario Newte, the two plaintiffs who prevailed in their lawsuit against the Los Angeles Fire Department. Plaintiffs' attorneys had sought just below $12.4 million.

Why it matters

The ruling trims the fee request by roughly 90 percent, reflecting the judge's view that the claims were narrower than the full lawsuit. The city had argued the original figures were excessive and grossly inflated, and the reduced award sets a concrete outcome for public-sector employment litigation in Los Angeles.

The Superior Court awarded $1.26 million in fees against a $12.4 million request, with each of two prevailing plaintiffs having received just over $600,000 in jury damages on March 3. The city's attorneys maintain the verdict forms correctly reflected the law, and whether that position will be pursued on appeal is not addressed.

The players

Los Angeles Fire Department

The municipal fire agency serving the City of Los Angeles, which was the defendant in the lawsuit and contended the fee figures were excessive.

Michael Shultz

The Los Angeles Superior Court judge who presided over the case, ruled on the fee request, and found the jury reached the correct result.

The details

Six plaintiffs filed an 89-page complaint in Los Angeles Superior Court in June 2021 against the Los Angeles Fire Department. The jury awarded damages only to Morris and Newte, and the judge denied a new trial to the four plaintiffs who received nothing, finding the jury reached the correct result after weighing the entire record.

Timeline

  1. June 2021: Six plaintiffs filed the lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court.

  2. March 3: A jury issued its verdict awarding damages to Newte and Morris.

  3. Thursday, November 19, 2026: Judge Michael Shultz ruled on the fee request.

Legal Context

The ruling applies the principle that attorneys' fees for a partial win must be proportionate to the claims that succeeded, a limit that shapes how California fee-shifting provisions are used against public agencies. Cases like this one show that prevailing-party status alone does not guarantee the full fee amount requested.

Residents of Los Angeles who interact with the city's fire department or who bring claims against public agencies may see how fee awards are determined when cases are partly won. The ruling signals that courts will scrutinize fee requests closely when plaintiffs prevail on only some claims.

The takeaway

Fee requests in multi-claim lawsuits are not automatically awarded at their full value. Parties litigating against public agencies should expect courts to reduce awards when only part of a case succeeds.

Further reading

For more on how courts handle legal disputes involving public agencies, explore Law coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by My News LA.

Live Poll

Do you trust local government to fairly handle discrimination complaints against its own workers?