Tulare County Joins Lawsuit Over Newsom Death Row Commutations

The Tulare County District Attorney's Office has joined a legal challenge to the Governor's planned commutation of California death sentences.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone civic building facade with a single bare flagpole, in oxblood and cream, evoking institutional opposition to clemency.
The Tulare County District Attorney's Office joined a lawsuit Monday challenging Governor Gavin Newsom's planned commutation of hundreds of California death row sentences. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should governors be allowed to commute death sentences without case-by-case review?

The Tulare County District Attorney's Office announced it has joined a lawsuit challenging Governor Gavin Newsom's planned commutation of California death row sentences. The suit, filed Monday by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation on behalf of the California District Attorneys Association and other organizations, alleges the Governor failed to provide legally required notice to district attorneys.

Why it matters

The lawsuit challenges whether the Governor can use clemency power to commute hundreds of death sentences without individualized review. Opponents describe the effort as a blanket statement of personal opposition to the death penalty, a policy that California voters have rejected at the ballot box.

Fifteen men who committed capital offenses in Tulare County currently sit on death row, and ten of them have two or more felony convictions. Inmates with two or more felony convictions require California Supreme Court approval for sentence commutation, and the court's position has not yet been reported.

The players

Gavin Newsom

Gavin Newsom is the Governor of California, a Democrat who has used his clemency power to commute death sentences and has said he expects the State Supreme Court to uphold his decision.

Criminal Justice Legal Foundation

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation is a California-based public interest legal organization that filed the lawsuit on behalf of prosecutors and other groups opposing the commutations.

California District Attorneys Association

The California District Attorneys Association is a statewide professional organization representing the state's elected district attorneys, on whose behalf the lawsuit was brought.

The details

The Tulare County District Attorney's Office announced its joining of the lawsuit on Thursday. The suit challenges the Governor's use of clemency power to commute hundreds of death sentences, and asserts that Penal Code requires a specific procedure the Governor did not follow. Newsom's action does not repeal the death penalty and applies only to inmates currently on death row.

Timeline

  1. 2012: California voters rejected Proposition 34, which would have abolished the death penalty.

  2. 2016: California voters rejected Proposition 62 and approved Proposition 66.

  3. Monday: The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed the lawsuit.

  4. Thursday: The Tulare County District Attorney's Office announced it had joined the lawsuit.

Legal Context

The lawsuit sits against the 2012 rejection of Proposition 34 and the 2016 approval of Proposition 66, both of which kept capital punishment in place in California. The dispute now turns on whether executive clemency can reshape a sentencing structure that voters have repeatedly endorsed, a question the state legislature and voters alone are empowered to resolve.

Residents of Tulare County and across California will see whether death sentences for inmates on death row can be commuted without the notice and review the lawsuit says state law requires. The outcome will determine whether the state's capital sentencing framework remains in force for those currently awaiting execution.

The takeaway

Voters decide whether the death penalty exists in California, but the courts decide whether a governor's clemency power can override that decision for inmates already on death row. Follow the State Supreme Court's response to see how that balance is resolved.

Further reading

For more on how the state's courts handle similar disputes, see the Law section of our California coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Porterville Recorder.

Live Poll

Should governors be allowed to commute death sentences without case-by-case review?