Victims Group Seeks Justice Evans' Recusal
Crime Victims United asks the California Supreme Court justice to step aside from review of Newsom's death sentence commutations.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should judges who once worked for a governor step aside from that governor's cases?
Crime Victims United has asked Justice Kelli Evans to recuse herself from the California Supreme Court's review of Governor Gavin Newsom's commutations of death sentences. The group, in a letter sent Friday and signed by its president, Harriet Salarno, argues Evans helped create and defend the governor's death penalty policy.
Why it matters
The request raises questions about judicial impartiality in a case that could determine the fate of hundreds of condemned inmates in California. The court's composition, with five Democratic appointees among six sitting justices, means the outcome of recusal decisions could shape how the commutation dispute is resolved.
Newsom commuted 548 death sentences on November 5, the largest such action in U.S. history, and 382 of those commutations require a majority vote of the court. The court has not yet addressed whether Justice Kelli Evans will step aside from the review.
The players
Crime Victims United
A victims' advocacy organization that has campaigned for stronger criminal penalties and victims' rights in California.
Kelli Evans
A California Supreme Court justice appointed by Gavin Newsom in 2022 who previously served as his deputy legal affairs secretary.
Gavin Newsom
The Governor of California, who ordered a moratorium on executions in 2019 and commuted 548 death sentences in November 2026.
Harriet Salarno
President of Crime Victims United, who signed the letter requesting Evans' recusal.
The details
Crime Victims United sent a letter to the court on Friday requesting Evans' recusal, arguing she served as Newsom's deputy legal affairs secretary and helped draft the 2019 moratorium on executions. The court is reviewing written arguments from opposing sides on the commutation issue.
Timeline
September 1979: Catina Salarno, 18, was shot and killed at the University of the Pacific.
2019: Newsom ordered a moratorium on executions.
2022: Newsom appointed Evans to the California Supreme Court.
November 5, 2026: Newsom commuted 548 death sentences to life without parole.
January 2027: Newsom leaves office; a court ruling is expected before then.
Legal Context
The dispute extends Governor Newsom's 2019 moratorium on executions, which Evans helped draft, into a clemency action affecting 548 sentences. The recusal request tests whether a justice who helped create that policy can fairly review its consequences on the state's high court.
The outcome determines whether 382 condemned inmates keep their death sentences or have them commuted to life without parole. Residents may see the ruling shape how future clemency decisions are made in California.
The takeaway
Recusal requests of this kind test whether judges who have worked on a policy can later rule on its legality, a question that will carry weight beyond this case.
What happens next
The California Supreme Court is expected to issue a ruling on the commutations before Newsom leaves office in January 2027.
Further reading
For related coverage of the state's legal battles, browse Law news on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by San Francisco Chronicle.
Live Poll
Should judges who once worked for a governor step aside from that governor's cases?






