Court Revives Lawsuit Over Revoked Concealed Carry License

A Ninth Circuit panel found the lower court erred in dismissing a Chula Vista man's suit against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Law

Court Revives Lawsuit Over Revoked Concealed Carry License

Live Poll

Should local sheriffs be able to revoke gun permits over group membership?

A unanimous Ninth Circuit panel, written by Judge Patrick Bumatay, revived Kenneth Shilling's lawsuit against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez and the county. Shilling alleges Martinez revoked his concealed carry license in December 2023 over his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club.

Why it matters

The panel found Martinez acted as a policymaker rather than a state official when revoking the license, a finding that bears on who can be held liable for such decisions. The case also raises questions about whether association with a private club can serve as grounds for revoking a constitutional right.

The Ninth Circuit panel ruled the lower court erred in dismissing the action against Sheriff Martinez and San Diego County, sending the case forward. The panel found Shilling sufficiently claimed his right to free association was infringed after the revocation of his Second Amendment right.

The players

Kelly Martinez

Sheriff of San Diego County, whose decision to revoke Shilling's concealed carry license is at the center of the lawsuit, and who was sued along with the county.

San Diego County

The Southern California county whose sheriff's office revoked the license and which was named as a defendant alongside Martinez.

Kenneth Shilling

A Chula Vista resident and longtime Chula Vista Elementary School District employee who filed the suit after his concealed carry license was revoked.

The details

Shilling received a concealed carry license in June 2022 under the previous sheriff. Martinez revoked it in December 2023 under California penal code's 'good moral character' requirement, which she based on her belief that the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club is a criminal street gang. The good moral character requirement was replaced with objective criteria in January 2024.

Timeline

  1. June 2022: Shilling's concealed carry license was issued under the previous sheriff.

  2. December 2023: Martinez revoked Shilling's license.

  3. January 2024: The good moral character requirement was replaced with objective criteria.

  4. June 2024: Shilling filed the lawsuit.

  5. Friday before November 20, 2026: The Ninth Circuit panel revived the lawsuit.

Legal Context

The revocation was made under California's 'good moral character' standard, which the state replaced with objective criteria in January 2024. The Ninth Circuit's ruling arrives as concealed carry licensing rules in the state have shifted away from discretionary judgments by individual sheriffs.

Gun owners in California who hold concealed carry licenses may face revocation under the state's current objective criteria, which replaced the discretionary good moral character standard in January 2024. The Ninth Circuit's revival of the suit means the question of whether association with a motorcycle club can justify revocation will continue in court.

The takeaway

Civil rights claims tied to licensing decisions can survive dismissal when a court finds the decision-maker acted as a local policymaker. Readers following Second Amendment disputes should watch how the case proceeds on remand.

Further reading

For related coverage of state court rulings, see California Law.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Court House News Service.

Live Poll

Should local sheriffs be able to revoke gun permits over group membership?