Supreme Court Declines Review of California Bias Course Law

The justices left in place a state mandate requiring implicit bias curriculum in physician continuing medical education courses.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

Supreme Court Declines Review of California Bias Course Law

Live Poll

Should doctors be required to take implicit bias training to renew their licenses?

The Supreme Court declined to take up a free-speech challenge to California's requirement that physician continuing medical education courses include implicit bias curriculum. Three justices, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, voted to hear the case, but four votes were required.

Why it matters

The decision leaves intact a state law that governs what licensed physicians in California must learn to renew their licenses. The case turns on whether state-mandated course content is government speech that falls outside First Amendment protection.

Three justices voted to take up the challenge, one short of the four votes required for review. California physicians must complete at least 50 hours of continuing medical education every two years, and the 2019 state law requires those courses to include implicit bias curriculum.

The players

Supreme Court of the United States

The nation's highest court, which decides whether to hear appeals and can overturn lower-court rulings on constitutional questions.

Azadeh Khatibi

A California ophthalmologist and frequent continuing medical education instructor who joined the challenge to the state's implicit bias requirement.

Do No Harm

A national advocacy group that opposes race-based policies in medicine and backed the legal challenge to the California requirement.

The details

Ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi and the group Do No Harm challenged the requirement, arguing the state compels instructors to deliver a contested ideological message. Khatibi, a frequent instructor of continuing medical education courses, is among the plaintiffs. The lower courts held that the First Amendment does not regulate the government's own speech and allowed the courses to proceed.

Timeline

  1. • 2019: California lawmakers passed the implicit bias course mandate.

  2. • November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court declined to review the challenge.

Legal Context

The Supreme Court's refusal to take up the case leaves the 2019 California law requiring implicit bias curriculum in physician continuing education in force. The lower courts' government-speech holding means the question of whether such state mandates violate the First Amendment remains unresolved at the high court.

California physicians who renew their licenses must continue to complete courses that include implicit bias curriculum, so those courses remain a required part of the renewal process. The ruling does not change the 50-hour continuing education requirement itself.

The takeaway

The Supreme Court's refusal to hear the case leaves the question of compelled course content for licensed professionals unsettled. Physicians renewing licenses in California should expect implicit bias material to remain part of required coursework.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Law on the Wisevoter politics section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Hill.

Live Poll

Should doctors be required to take implicit bias training to renew their licenses?