Study Finds School Closures Don't Improve District Budgets
Stanford research on 796 California districts finds closures cut spending and revenue by roughly the same amount.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Administration

Live Poll
Do you think closing schools is a good way to save money?
A study by Stanford economist Francis A. Pearman II found that school closures do not improve district budgets. Districts that closed schools spent about $440 less per student, while revenue fell by nearly the same amount.
Why it matters
Closures are often proposed as a way to save money, but the findings suggest lost enrollment and state per-student funding offset expected savings. For California, where state funding follows students, districts facing declining enrollment may need to weigh closures against other options.
The study compared spending and revenue across 796 California districts over nine years, finding closing districts spent about $440 less per student while revenue fell by nearly the same amount. The research covers the period before the pandemic, so current conditions remain unmeasured.
The players
Francis A. Pearman II
Stanford University economist whose study examined the budgetary effects of school closures in California districts.
The details
The study found closures produced no measurable improvement in district budgets. The number of principals, total district staff and teachers did not measurably change after closures, and closing districts had already lost enrollment before shutting schools.
Timeline
The study covers a nine-year period of California district closures.
The California research reflects conditions before the pandemic.
The findings were reported on November 17, 2026.
Season Trajectory
A Michigan study found no lasting average harm to students' test scores after closures, and this California research adds that closures also fail to deliver the budget relief districts often expect. Together the two studies shift the debate from whether closures hurt students to whether they accomplish their stated financial goals.
For California families, school closures can mean longer bus rides, changed attendance zones and disruption to familiar programs. The study suggests these changes may not translate into the budget savings districts often cite as the reason for closing schools.
The takeaway
Districts weighing closures should look beyond projected savings, since lost enrollment can cancel out the revenue gains. Parents and community members can ask for district-level spending and enrollment projections before supporting or opposing a closure plan.
Further reading
Explore more on Administration to see how districts make decisions about closures and budgets.
Source note: This article includes information reported by FOX 13 News Utah (KSTU).
Live Poll
Do you think closing schools is a good way to save money?










