Herbstreit Questions CFP Ranking of SEC Teams
Kirk Herbstreit criticized the College Football Playoff committee for placing four SEC teams with four losses each at Nos. 21-25.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Football

Live Poll
Do you trust college football's playoff rankings to be fair?
On "The Pat McAfee Show" on Thursday, Kirk Herbstreit questioned the College Football Playoff committee's latest rankings, which placed South Carolina No. 21, Oklahoma No. 22, Florida No. 24 and Mississippi No. 25, each with four losses. Separately, Indiana coach Curt Cignetti denied reports linking him to the Michigan head coaching job, calling them "Fake news."
Why it matters
Herbstreit said the bottom of the rankings did not make sense given South Carolina's 34-6 loss at Arkansas and the inconsistent performances of Oklahoma and Florida. The committee's new strength-of-conference metric also surprised him, raising questions about how the playoff field is being shaped.
South Carolina lost 34-6 at Arkansas, a team that was 3-6 entering the game, while Oklahoma is 4-3 in SEC play and ranks No. 106 in FBS scoring offense. Florida is 2-4 since the start of October, and Arizona, moved up four spots to No. 19, lost 40-39 at home to No. 2 Utah.
The players
Kirk Herbstreit
A longtime ESPN college football commentator and analyst known for his broadcasts and studio work.
Curt Cignetti
The head football coach at Indiana, who has built a reputation as one of college football's prominent program leaders.
The details
Herbstreit made his comments on "The Pat McAfee Show" Thursday, criticizing the committee's bottom-of-the-rankings placement. South Carolina played without quarterback LaNorris Sellers, who was out with an ankle injury, when it lost at Arkansas. Cignetti responded to the Michigan report by posting on X that it was "Fake news created by three SEC media writers."
Timeline
Last Saturday: Arizona lost 40-39 at home to No. 2 Utah.
Thursday: Herbstreit criticized the CFP rankings on "The Pat McAfee Show."
October: Cignetti recorded a video saying he plans to retire at Indiana.
Through 2033: Cignetti's Indiana contract extension runs.
Season Trajectory
The committee's placement of four SEC teams with four losses each at Nos. 21-25 shapes which teams remain in playoff contention late in the season. The strength-of-conference metric, which Herbstreit said surprised him, now plays a visible role in determining the bottom of the ranked field.
The rankings shape which SEC teams remain in the playoff conversation, affecting how fans and bettors read the remaining schedule. Cignetti's $15 million buyout and contract through 2033 mean any move to Michigan would carry a significant financial cost for Indiana.
The takeaway
The committee's placement of teams with identical records shows how strength-of-conference weighting can separate teams that look similar on the field. Readers tracking the playoff race should watch whether that metric changes the final field.
Further reading
Follow the latest in Football coverage for context on playoff rankings and coaching news.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Longview Daily News.
Live Poll
Do you trust college football's playoff rankings to be fair?





