Herbstreit Calls Oklahoma Season Trash on McAfee Show
Kirk Herbstreit criticized Oklahoma's season during Thursday's College Football Playoff rankings discussion, drawing responses from fans on social media.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Football

On Thursday's edition of The Pat McAfee Show, ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit called Oklahoma's season trash while discussing the College Football Playoff rankings. Oklahoma, now 6-4, entered the rankings at No. 22, and fans criticized his assessment online.
Why it matters
Herbstreit's comments add to ongoing debate over how the College Football Playoff committee and analysts evaluate teams with mixed records. The reaction shows how quickly national commentary can draw responses from a team's fan base.
Oklahoma sits at No. 22 in the College Football Playoff rankings with a 6-4 record, including a 27-24 win over then-No. 1 Texas and a 24-17 win over Ole Miss. The source does not explain how these results will affect the team's standing going forward.
The players
Kirk Herbstreit
Kirk Herbstreit is a longtime college football analyst known for his work on ESPN broadcasts and college football coverage.
Pat McAfee
Pat McAfee is a former NFL punter who hosts The Pat McAfee Show, a sports talk program known for its college football and NFL commentary.
The details
Herbstreit made the remarks while discussing the rankings with host Pat McAfee on the show. Fans responded to the comments through social media posts.
Timeline
Thursday, November 19, 2026: Herbstreit calls Oklahoma's season trash on The Pat McAfee Show.
November 2026: Oklahoma defeats Florida at the Swamp and Ole Miss.
Season Trajectory
Oklahoma's No. 22 placement in the College Football Playoff rankings puts it on the edge of postseason contention as the season winds down. Herbstreit's criticism reflects how national analysts weigh a 6-4 record against the Texas and Ole Miss wins.
Oklahoma's ranking and record may affect how fantasy and bracket players view the team's remaining schedule. Fans following the College Football Playoff race can use the current No. 22 placement as a baseline for tracking movement.
The takeaway
National analyst commentary can shape how fans and observers read a team's season, even when the rankings themselves remain fluid. Watching how Oklahoma's remaining games affect its CFP position will show whether the criticism holds.
Further reading
Explore more Football coverage for context on how the season is shaping up.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Pro Football Network.





