Judge Declines Order Restoring VA Union Bargaining Rights
A federal judge refused a conditional ruling that would have restored collective bargaining rights for VA employees after the department terminated its contract with AFGE.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Unions

Live Poll
Should federal agencies be allowed to end union contracts with their employees?
U.S. District Judge Melissa DuBose declined to issue a conditional ruling restoring Department of Veterans Affairs collective bargaining rights, acknowledging that VA management has sought to subvert her prior decisions. The VA formally terminated its collective bargaining agreement with the American Federation of Government Employees in October 2026, after the agreement's August 8, 2026 expiration date.
Why it matters
The dispute centers on whether the VA triggered an automatic contract extension provision, a question at the heart of the department's appeals. The outcome will determine whether the union's bargaining rights for VA workers are restored or remain terminated during litigation.
DuBose previously found the VA likely violated employees' First Amendment rights, and a three-judge First Circuit panel found her August enforcement decision improperly modified her earlier injunction. The union has asked DuBose to issue an indicative ruling, and the VA's opening appellate briefs are due December 23, 2026.
The players
Department of Veterans Affairs
The federal agency responsible for health care and benefits for U.S. military veterans, which terminated its collective bargaining agreement with the union and is appealing the injunction.
American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE)
One of the largest federal employee unions in the United States, representing VA workers whose bargaining agreement was terminated.
Judge Melissa DuBose
A U.S. District Judge who previously found the VA likely violated employees' First Amendment rights and declined to issue a conditional ruling restoring bargaining rights.
The details
In August 2026, DuBose moved to enforce her prior order preserving the collective bargaining agreement, but the First Circuit found that decision improperly modified her earlier injunction. The VA announced in summer 2026 that it planned to end its contracts with AFGE, and it formally terminated the agreement in October 2026. The union stated it has been in active negotiations on bargaining ground rules.
Timeline
August 8, 2026: VA collective bargaining agreement with AFGE set to expire.
August 2026: DuBose moved to enforce her prior order preserving the agreement.
October 2026: VA formally terminated its agreement with AFGE.
November 20, 2026: DuBose declined to issue a conditional ruling restoring bargaining rights.
December 23, 2026: VA opening appellate briefs due.
Legal Standing
The case turns on whether the VA's termination of its AFGE contract can stand while the courts resolve First Amendment claims and the scope of prior injunctions under federal labor-management rules. The First Circuit's finding that DuBose's enforcement order modified her earlier injunction shapes how far lower courts can go in restoring bargaining rights during appeal.
VA employees represented by AFGE currently have no contractually guaranteed bargaining agreement while the appeals proceed. Whether the agreement is restored will determine the terms under which those workers negotiate pay, working conditions and grievance procedures.
The takeaway
The outcome of these appeals will set a precedent for how federal agencies can end union contracts during active First Amendment litigation. Readers following federal workforce policy should watch the December 23 briefing deadline.
What happens next
VA opening appellate briefs are due December 23, 2026, and the court's handling of the union's request for an indicative ruling is pending.
Further reading
For more on labor fights in the federal workforce, see Unions coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Government Executive.
Live Poll
Should federal agencies be allowed to end union contracts with their employees?






