AT&T Pension Transfer Appeal Sought in Court
Parties ask for immediate appeal on whether participants can pursue claims over the $8.05 billion pension risk transfer.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Retirement Planning

The parties in Piercy et al. v. AT&T Inc. et al. filed a joint request for an immediate appeal on November 18, asking whether plaintiffs can pursue pension risk transfer claims against AT&T. The request follows a September 28 ruling by a judge in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts that dismissed claims against AT&T related to its $8.05 billion pension risk transfer to Athene Annuity and Life Insurance Co.
Why it matters
The request highlights a five-to-four split among federal appellate courts on whether plaintiffs have standing to challenge pension risk transfer transactions. The U.S. 1st Circuit Court of Appeals has not issued a controlling opinion on the issue, so an appellate ruling could clarify whether participants in corporate pension plans may bring such challenges.
The $8.05 billion transfer to Athene is the central transaction at issue, and the appellate courts are divided five-to-four on plaintiffs' standing to challenge such transfers. Whether the 1st Circuit will take up the question has not been determined.
The players
AT&T Inc.
AT&T is a major American telecommunications company and the sponsor of the pension plan whose $8.05 billion risk transfer to Athene is at the center of the lawsuit.
Athene Annuity and Life Insurance Co.
Athene is an insurance company that received the $8.05 billion pension obligation transfer from AT&T and serves as the annuity provider at issue in the case.
State Street Global Advisors Trust Co.
State Street Global Advisors is an investment management firm whose claims in the case were allowed to proceed after the September 28 ruling.
The details
The district court's September 28 order dismissed claims against AT&T but allowed claims against State Street Global Advisors Trust Co. to proceed. The dismissal followed an August 31 report and recommendation by Magistrate Judge Paul Levenson, who found plaintiffs failed to show AT&T was involved in the May 2023 selection of Athene as annuity provider. The parties cited the district court's opinion in Philip Morris Inc. v. Harshbarger in support of interlocutory review.
Timeline
May 2023: Athene was selected as the annuity provider.
August 31: Magistrate Judge Paul Levenson issued a report and recommendation.
September 28: Judge ruled claims against AT&T dismissed.
November 18: Parties filed a joint request for immediate appeal.
Big Picture
The case tests how ERISA fiduciary standards apply when corporate pension sponsors transfer obligations to insurers, and whether plan participants have standing to challenge those transfers. Federal appellate courts remain split five-to-four on the standing question.
Participants in corporate pension plans that have transferred obligations to insurers may have limited ability to challenge those transfers depending on how the appeal is resolved. Plan participants should review their plan documents and annuity provider information to understand who now holds their benefit obligations.
The takeaway
Pension risk transfers move retirement obligations from employers to insurers, and courts are still divided on whether workers can contest those moves. Participants may want to confirm which insurer now backs their pension benefits.
Further reading
For broader background on how pension obligations are handled, see Retirement Planning.
Source note: This article includes information reported by PLANADVISER.






