Yankees Weigh Trading Pitching Youth This Offseason
Ken Rosenthal examines what the Yankees could receive for Will Warren or Ryan Weathers after the Dustin May contract with the White Sox.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Baseball

The Chicago White Sox signed Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract, averaging $17.5 million per season. Ken Rosenthal, writing for The Athletic, used that deal as a benchmark for what the New York Yankees could receive in a trade for Will Warren or Ryan Weathers.
Why it matters
Brian Cashman said he would consider trading young pitching this offseason and has received countless interest in the Yankees' pitching. The Yankees face a decision on whether to move one of two young arms with remaining club control.
Will Warren is 27 with four seasons of Yankees club control, while Ryan Weathers is 26 with two seasons of control. Rosenthal projects Warren near the league minimum in 2027 and Weathers at about $3 million in his second year of arbitration.
The players
New York Yankees
The New York Yankees are a Major League Baseball franchise based in New York City and one of the sport's most storied clubs.
Chicago White Sox
The Chicago White Sox are a Major League Baseball franchise based in Chicago that signed pitcher Dustin May to a three-year deal.
Brian Cashman
Brian Cashman is the longtime general manager of the New York Yankees who has overseen the club's roster-building decisions.
Ken Rosenthal
Ken Rosenthal is a veteran MLB insider and columnist who writes for The Athletic.
The details
Ken Rosenthal wrote about the possible return for Will Warren or Ryan Weathers in an article published November 19, 2026, using the Dustin May contract as a reference point. Cashman has said he received interest in the Yankees' pitching last summer as well as this offseason.
Timeline
Wednesday, November 18, 2026: Chicago White Sox announce the Dustin May contract.
November 19, 2026: Ken Rosenthal's article on Yankees pitching trades is published.
2027: Will Warren's projected near-minimum salary season.
Second year of arbitration: Ryan Weathers' projected salary of about $3 million.
Season Trajectory
The Dustin May deal sets a concrete price point that clubs and executives can use when weighing young pitching in trades. For the Yankees, the decision on Warren or Weathers hinges on how that benchmark compares with the value of the club control each pitcher still has.
A trade of Warren or Weathers would change the Yankees' rotation depth and could shift how fantasy managers value those pitchers. Warren's four years of control and Weathers' two years give the club different timelines to weigh before any deal.
The takeaway
Trade benchmarks like the Dustin May contract give fans a concrete way to measure whether a team is getting fair value for young pitching. Watching how these comparisons play out this offseason will show how clubs are pricing young arms.
Further reading
For more on the offseason moves shaping the league, see Baseball coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by ClutchPoints.






