Survey Finds Customers Would Switch After Closures
A Hanover Insurance Group and Statista survey of US consumers finds most would temporarily shop elsewhere if a preferred small business closed unexpectedly.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
If your favorite local shop closed suddenly, would you switch to a competitor?
Sixty percent of 500 US consumers surveyed said they would temporarily shop with a competitor if a preferred small business closed due to an unexpected event, and 54% said they would begin seeking alternatives in less than a week. The findings come from the 2026 Small Business Pulse Report: Reputation, Risk and Resilience.
Why it matters
The survey suggests that a disruption a small business cannot easily recover from can translate into lost customers and revenue, not just a temporary pause. Only about one-third of US small businesses carry business interruption coverage, which bears directly on how much of that risk they absorb.
The Statista survey polled 500 US consumers aged 18 to 64 who buy from small businesses at least monthly, and 60% said they would temporarily shop with a competitor after an unexpected closure. The research does not measure how many of those customers would permanently switch or how long closures would need to last to change buying habits.
The players
Hanover Insurance Group
Hanover Insurance Group is a US property and casualty insurer that serves individuals and businesses, including small business owners.
Statista
Statista is a German-founded statistics and market research company that conducts online consumer surveys for clients worldwide.
The details
Respondents rated serious product safety issues (73%) and customer data or privacy breaches (73%) among the top trust-damaging events, followed by evidence of employee mistreatment or injury (69%). Reliable products and services (68%), data protection (62%) and transparent communication during problems (54%) ranked as the top trust-building factors.
Timeline
November 19, 2026: Article reporting the survey findings was published.
Market Landscape
The findings sit within the Hanover's 2026 Small Business Pulse Report: Reputation, Risk and Resilience, which frames reputation and insurance coverage as linked components of small business survival. The gap between the one-third of businesses carrying business interruption coverage and the 94% of owners worried their insurance may not cover a loss highlights where protection falls short of concern.
Small business owners without business interruption coverage may face lost customers during an unexpected closure, even after reopening. Customers who rely on a local business may need to plan for temporary alternatives when a favorite shop closes unexpectedly.
The takeaway
Small businesses that communicate openly during problems and protect customer data may be better positioned to keep customers through a disruption. Owners should review whether their insurance covers business interruption before a closure occurs.
Further reading
Explore more on Insurance coverage options for small businesses facing unexpected disruption.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.
Live Poll
If your favorite local shop closed suddenly, would you switch to a competitor?






