First-Year Policyholders Drive Auto Insurance Losses

LexisNexis data show new auto insurance customers account for 40% of lost U.S. policies, as shopping activity stays near record levels.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Insurance

Bold flat-color vector editorial illustration of a set of car keys in front of a row of identical unmarked sedans, conveying auto insurance customer switching.
LexisNexis data show first-year auto insurance policyholders account for 40% of lost U.S. policies as 47.2% of policies were shopped in the past year. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Did you shop around for your auto insurance in the past year?

First-year auto insurance policyholders account for 40% of all lost U.S. policies, according to a LexisNexis analysis in its Q3 2026 U.S. Insurance Demand Meter report. Nearly half of U.S. auto policies in force, 47.2%, were shopped at least once in the prior 12 months as of Q3 2026.

Why it matters

The findings point to a market where newer customers switch carriers at high rates, which can affect pricing and retention for insurers. LexisNexis said affordability pressures and AI-driven shopping may prevent the usual fourth-quarter shopping lull from materializing.

LexisNexis measured policy losses over 60-day periods against active policies, finding 18% annualized loss with 70% of lost policies staying in the market. The report does not identify the reasons first-year customers leave, and it has not confirmed whether the expected fourth-quarter shopping slowdown will occur.

The players

LexisNexis

LexisNexis is a global data and analytics company whose U.S. Insurance Demand Meter tracks consumer shopping and policy activity in the insurance market.

The details

Auto insurance shopping grew 0.7% year over year in Q3 2026, while non-standard auto shopping rose 5.4% after contracting 9% in Q2. The exclusive agent channel recorded 4.5% shopping growth, and the number of states with positive shopping growth fell to 28.

Timeline

  1. Q1 2026: a record 47.3% of policies in force were shopped in the prior 12 months.

  2. Q2 2026: non-standard auto shopping contracted 9%, and 42 states posted positive shopping growth.

  3. Q3 2026: LexisNexis recorded 0.7% quarterly year-over-year shopping growth.

  4. November 12, 2026: LexisNexis published the U.S. Insurance Demand Meter with its policy loss findings.

Market Dynamics

The findings extend the LexisNexis U.S. Insurance Demand Meter series, which has tracked shopping activity across quarters, by adding a measure of how many newly acquired policies leave the market. Together, the figures show shopping activity holding near record levels while growth slows in most states.

Drivers who recently bought auto coverage may see carriers compete more actively for renewals as shopping stays elevated. Comparing quotes before renewal can help consumers avoid unnecessary lapses or price increases.

The takeaway

Auto insurance customers are shopping more often and switching at high rates, especially in their first year. Reviewing your policy and comparing rates before renewal can help you keep coverage affordable.

Further reading

Explore more on insurance trends and auto coverage shopping.

Live Poll

Did you shop around for your auto insurance in the past year?