Chris Simms Buys $4.5M Sutton Tower Condo

The former NFL quarterback purchased a New York City residence after selling his Greenwich, Connecticut farmhouse for $5.5 million.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Football

Gouache-painted editorial illustration of a tall city tower beside a small rural farmhouse, joined by a thin path, in warm ochre and sage tones.
Former NFL quarterback Chris Simms bought a $4.5 million Sutton Tower condo in Manhattan after selling his Greenwich, Connecticut farmhouse for $5.5 million. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you consider moving to a city apartment from a country home?

Former NFL quarterback Chris Simms purchased a $4.5 million three-bedroom residence in Sutton Tower in New York City. The move follows the sale of his Greenwich, Connecticut property for $5.5 million.

Why it matters

The transaction reflects a shift from a rural Connecticut estate to an urban Manhattan home, a pattern many high-net-worth buyers pursue. It also illustrates how a property's sale price can differ substantially from its initial listing after multiple reductions.

The Greenwich farmhouse sold for $5.5 million after being listed at $8 million and reduced three times, including $500,000 and $600,000 cuts. The Connecticut property spans 3,669 square feet with five bedrooms and five bathrooms.

The players

Chris Simms

Chris Simms is a former NFL quarterback who was drafted by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2003 and retired in 2010.

Monica Webster

Monica Webster is a real estate agent with Douglas Elliman who handled the listing of the Greenwich property.

The details

Simms bought the Sutton Tower residence, which has floor-to-ceiling windows, a chef's kitchen and panoramic views, and the building was completed in 2022 by architect Thomas Juul-Hansen. He had listed the 1725 Greenwich farmhouse with Monica Webster of Douglas Elliman, and he and his wife said they wanted more space for their horses when they originally chose it.

Timeline

  1. 1725: Greenwich farmhouse originally built.

  2. 2019: Simms purchased the Greenwich property for $2.5 million.

  3. Feb. 6, 2026: Greenwich property first listed for sale.

Roadmap

Sutton Tower, completed in 2022 by architect Thomas Juul-Hansen, adds to the wave of new luxury condominiums in Manhattan. Simms's move from a Connecticut farmhouse to a newly built tower follows a broader pattern of affluent buyers trading suburban estates for city living.

For buyers weighing a move between a suburban estate and a city condo, the Greenwich sale shows how multiple price reductions can bring a $8 million listing down to $5.5 million. Prospective purchasers in Manhattan can also compare new-build options like Sutton Tower when considering space and amenities.

The takeaway

Sellers who reduce asking prices in steps can still reach a sale, but the final price may land well below the original listing. Buyers evaluating a move between suburban and urban homes should weigh space needs, such as room for animals, against access to city amenities.

Further reading

Explore more Football coverage for context on the athletes and careers shaping stories like this one.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Real Estate News & Insights | realtor.com®.

Live Poll

Would you consider moving to a city apartment from a country home?