Giants Land J.J. McCarthy in Trade With Vikings

New York acquires the former first-round quarterback from Minnesota for a Day 3 draft pick as it chases the NFC East lead.

Updated on Nov. 8, 2026 in Football

Giants Land J.J. McCarthy in Trade With Vikings

The New York Giants acquired quarterback J.J. McCarthy from the Minnesota Vikings in exchange for a Day 3 pick. McCarthy, drafted by Minnesota in 2024 as a first-round selection, was third on the Vikings depth chart at the time of the trade.

Why it matters

The deal gives the Giants a quarterback with arm strength and a skill set they wanted, while the Vikings move on from a passer who had not found a regular role. For a Giants team currently atop the NFC East, the addition adds depth at a position of need.

McCarthy's last two games produced a 95.2 passer rating, 495 yards, one touchdown and one interception. The Giants gave up only a Day 3 pick, and it remains unclear how much game time he will receive behind the current starter.

The players

J.J. McCarthy

McCarthy is a quarterback who was selected 10th overall by the Minnesota Vikings in the 2024 NFL Draft out of Michigan.

New York Giants

The Giants are a franchise in the National Football League based in East Rutherford, New Jersey, and compete in the NFC East.

Minnesota Vikings

The Vikings are a franchise in the National Football League based in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and compete in the NFC North.

Joe Schoen

Schoen is the general manager of the New York Giants who oversaw the team's roster decisions and explained the trade on Move the Sticks.

The details

The Giants front office spent time with McCarthy personally and through mental and physical evaluations before the draft, and identified a trade opportunity when Vikings third-string quarterback status became apparent during Kyler Murray's injury. Giants general manager Joe Schoen explained the rationale on Move the Sticks on Oct. 29.

Timeline

  1. 2024: Minnesota drafts McCarthy in the first round.

  2. Oct. 29: Schoen explains the trade rationale on Move the Sticks.

  3. Nov. 7: Giants co-owner John Mara comments on McCarthy in the New York Post.

  4. Nov. 8: Ian Warner comments on McCarthy on NFL Network.

Season Trajectory

Drafted 10th overall in 2024, McCarthy was expected to be a long-term starter for Minnesota, making his move to New York a notable reversal of that expectation. The trade adds a young passer to a Giants team that now sits atop the NFC East and is pushing for the playoffs.

The trade adds McCarthy as a potential depth option behind the Giants' current starter, which could matter for fantasy managers tracking backup quarterbacks. The Giants' playoff push makes his role in the rotation worth following through the rest of the season.

The takeaway

The trade shows how a single late-round pick can reshape a quarterback depth chart when a team identifies an opening. Fans tracking the Giants' playoff chase should watch how quickly McCarthy earns snaps.

Further reading

For more NFL coverage, see the Football section.