Judge Orders LSU Apology Over AI Hallucination Claim

A federal judge directed Louisiana State University's legal team to publicly express regret for language questioning SEC case citations.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Artificial Intelligence

Judge Orders LSU Apology Over AI Hallucination Claim

Judge Annemarie Carney Axon directed LSU's legal team to publicly express regret for its Oct. 20 filing, which used the word "hallucination" to describe SEC case citations. The SEC had earlier filed a motion to strike that language, after its attorneys used an artificial intelligence tool to help prepare a filing.

Why it matters

The dispute highlights how courts are handling accusations that legal filings contain fabricated or negligently sourced citations generated with AI tools. Judge Axon ruled she could not strike the language because it is not a pleading, but she ordered the public expression of regret.

The SEC's Oct. 13 brief was prepared with the AI tool Harvey, and the SEC may address three cases in a sur reply permitted by the judge. Whether the cited cases were negligently sourced or hallucinated has not been resolved by the court.

The players

Louisiana State University

A public research university in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and a member of the Southeastern Conference, which is a defendant in the SEC's lawsuit over football player rostering.

Southeastern Conference

A collegiate athletic conference of public universities across the southern United States, whose enforcement arm, the Securities and Exchange Commission, brought the lawsuit against LSU.

The details

Judge Axon offered LSU the option to file a motion replacing a page of its Oct. 20 filing containing the word "hallucination." One LSU attorney conceded it was not appropriate to accuse another member of the bar of failing to verify citations.

Timeline

  1. Sept. 3, 2026: The SEC filed its lawsuit against LSU over football player rostering.

  2. Oct. 13, 2026: The SEC filed a brief prepared with the AI tool Harvey.

  3. Oct. 20, 2026: LSU filed a brief using the word "hallucination."

  4. Oct. 22, 2026: The SEC moved to strike the language from LSU's brief.

  5. Nov. 18, 2026: The judge held the hearing in Birmingham and directed the LSU apology.

Roadmap

Courts have increasingly confronted fabricated citations generated by AI tools, following the 2023 Mata v. Avianca sanctions in New York federal court. This Alabama dispute shows the same concern now surfacing as accusations between opposing lawyers.

Lawyers who rely on AI tools to draft filings face scrutiny over whether citations are verified before submission. Litigants who accuse opposing counsel of hallucinated citations may themselves face judicial rebuke.

The takeaway

Verifying every citation before filing remains essential when AI tools are involved, and accusations of fabricated sources carry professional risk for the accuser as well. Courts are signaling they will police how these disputes are conducted.

Further reading

For more on how courts are grappling with AI tools, see Artificial Intelligence coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Town Talk.