Durbin Grills Judicial Nominees Over Comey Case
Senate Judiciary Committee questioned nominees Philip Aubart and Brian Meyers at a confirmation hearing over their roles in the prosecution of James Comey.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Do you trust federal judges chosen from prosecutors involved in politically charged cases?
Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., questioned judicial nominees Philip Aubart and Brian Meyers during a Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing over their roles in the prosecution of former FBI Director James Comey. Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., who endorsed both nominees, disputed that they had any ties to the Comey case.
Why it matters
The hearing centers on whether officials involved in a politically sensitive prosecution should be eligible for lifetime federal judgeships. Court filings describing Aubart's involvement and Meyers's signing of a search warrant put the nominees' past work directly before senators weighing their confirmation.
FBI records filed in court show Aubart was deeply involved in the Comey investigation, and Meyers signed a May search warrant for Comey's email records. Tillis, who has served 12 years on the committee, asserted the nominees had no connection to the case, and what Aubart did beyond those filings remains unclear.
The players
Dick Durbin
Durbin is a Democratic senator from Illinois who has long been a senior member of the Senate Judiciary Committee and questioned the nominees.
Thom Tillis
Tillis is a Republican senator from North Carolina who has served 12 years on the Judiciary Committee and endorsed both nominees.
James Comey
Comey is a former FBI Director whose prosecution for allegedly threatening President Donald Trump's life is the subject of the hearing.
The details
Comey was prosecuted for allegedly threatening President Donald Trump's life by posting a photo of seashells arranged to say "86 47." Durbin referenced Tillis's August comments that anyone involved in the prosecution was a "bonehead" and should lose their job, while Tillis endorsed Aubart, First Assistant U.S. Attorney in Eastern North Carolina, and Meyers, a U.S. Magistrate Judge, for federal judgeships.
Timeline
August 2026: Tillis said anyone involved in the Comey prosecution was a "bonehead" who should lose their job.
May 2026: Meyers approved and signed a search warrant for Comey's email records.
October 2026: POLITICO reported Tillis's endorsement of Aubart and Meyers.
November 18, 2026: Senate Judiciary Committee held the confirmation hearing where Durbin and Tillis clashed.
Political Context
Republican senators have generally defended the Justice Department's handling of cases against Trump critics, while Democrats have argued such prosecutions raise concerns about political retribution. Tillis's denial of any ties to the Comey case reflects that partisan divide over whether prosecutors involved should be disqualified from judicial service.
The confirmation outcome will determine whether Aubart and Meyers gain lifetime federal judgeships with decisions affecting litigants nationwide. Voters and litigants can track the committee vote and any floor action that follows.
The takeaway
Confirmation hearings give the public a rare view of how a nominee's past government work is weighed against judicial qualifications. Watching how senators handle prior roles in contested prosecutions can clarify what standards apply to future federal appointments.
Further reading
Explore more coverage in Law for context on how federal judicial nominations are evaluated.
Source note: This article includes information reported by POLITICO.
Live Poll
Do you trust federal judges chosen from prosecutors involved in politically charged cases?






