AM Best Keeps U.S. Personal Lines Outlook Stable

The rating agency says improved rate adequacy and underwriting are supporting profitability in the segment, though claim severity remains elevated.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Insurance

Bold flat-color vector editorial illustration of a weathered roof shingle with hail-dented impact marks on a cream field, evoking property claim strain in personal insurance.
Insurers' personal lines profitability is stabilizing, AM Best said, as improved rate adequacy and underwriting lift results despite elevated claim severity. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust insurance companies to keep rates fair for customers?

AM Best maintained its stable outlook for the U.S. personal lines insurance segment. The agency cited rebounding profitability, improving underwriting performance, and greater net investment income.

Why it matters

Stable outlooks signal that rating analysts expect current profit gains to hold, which bears on premiums and coverage availability for drivers and homeowners. Softening reinsurance pricing and persistent claim severity leave the margin picture uncertain.

AM Best's personal auto and personal lines outlooks have been stable since November 2024, and its homeowners outlook was revised to stable in December 2025. The agency has not yet said how long current profit gains will persist as pricing competition intensifies.

The players

AM Best

AM Best is a credit rating agency specializing in the insurance industry, whose outlooks and ratings are widely used by insurers, brokers and investors.

The details

AM Best said improved rate adequacy and refined underwriting support results in the personal lines segment, and earnings are improving through rebounding underwriting performance and greater net investment income. Claim severity remains high compared with older years, property-related severity is stabilizing, and liability claim severity continues to rise. Regulators have increased scrutiny of the fairness, affordability and application of insurance rates.

Timeline

  1. November 2024: AM Best sets personal auto and personal lines outlooks to stable.

  2. December 2025: AM Best revises the homeowners segment outlook to stable.

  3. December 3, 2026, 11 a.m. ET: AM Best senior analysts present 2027 outlooks at a virtual briefing.

Market Dynamics

The stable outlook follows the early-2020s squeeze from economic, medical and social inflation, severe weather and costlier reinsurance, which pushed carriers to seek substantial rate increases. Rate adequacy has since improved, and the segment is now recovering as those pressures ease.

Stable profitability outlooks suggest that auto and home insurance premiums may stop rising as sharply, though rates still reflect higher claim costs. Drivers and homeowners should compare quotes, since sophisticated pricing by advanced carriers can leave less refined competitors with riskier customers.

The takeaway

Stable outlooks reflect recovery, not a return to cheap coverage. Comparing quotes each renewal cycle remains the most reliable way to control insurance costs.

What happens next

AM Best senior analysts will present their 2027 outlooks at a virtual briefing on December 3, 2026, at 11 a.m. ET.

Further reading

For more on how carriers price coverage, see Insurance coverage and rates in the United States.

More information

The full analysis is available on the Full Best's Market Segment Report purchase page.

Live Poll

Do you trust insurance companies to keep rates fair for customers?