Commercial Motor Insurers Narrow Sector Underwriting Loss

AM Best reports the US commercial motor market's 2025 underwriting loss shrank 55% from 2024 as results improve.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Insurance

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of identical commercial box trucks parked nose-to-tail in a loading yard, rendered in deep red, cream, and slate.
US commercial motor insurers cut their sector underwriting loss to $2.2 billion in 2025, a 55% reduction from 2024, according to AM Best. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you expect your car insurance premiums to rise next year?

AM Best identified improving underwriting results in the US commercial motor insurance market, with the sector's 2025 underwriting loss narrowing to USD $2.2 billion. The loss was a 55% reduction compared with 2024.

Why it matters

The shift signals that commercial auto insurers are regaining profitability after a period of heavy losses, which bears on the premiums businesses across the United States pay to insure their vehicle fleets. Sustained gains will depend on how insurers manage liability exposure and rising claims and repair costs.

AM Best's sector figures show the commercial motor liability segment recorded an underwriting loss above USD $4.6 billion in 2025, while the physical damage segment posted a gain of USD $2.4 billion. The analysis does not resolve whether liability losses will narrow further as adverse reserve development continues.

The players

AM Best

AM Best is a credit rating agency that publishes independent analysis of the insurance industry.

Progressive Insurance Group

Progressive Insurance Group is a large US auto insurer and the leading commercial motor insurer in the country by direct premiums written.

Travelers Group

Travelers Group is a major US property and casualty insurer that ranks second in commercial motor direct premiums written behind Progressive.

The details

AM Best's analysis draws on claims costs, premium pricing, reserve development and social inflation across the sector. Physical damage results held up despite higher prices for components in newer vehicles and rising labour costs, while overall reserve deficiencies have decreased.

Timeline

  1. 2025: Sector underwriting loss narrowed to USD $2.2 billion.

  2. First half of 2026: Direct loss ratio reached 66.1, slightly below the prior year.

Legislative Precedent

Florida's enacted tort reforms are cited as a possible model for other states weighing similar changes to liability rules. The sector's improving results give those states a comparison point as they consider their own legal reforms.

Businesses running commercial vehicle fleets may see the pricing environment shift as insurers recover from heavy losses. Fleet operators with active monitoring and maintenance programs have seen fewer preventable accidents, which can help control their coverage costs.

The takeaway

Commercial fleet owners should track their claims history and maintenance records, since insurers increasingly reward proactive risk management. Watching how states handle liability reform can also signal where premiums may head next.

Further reading

For more on how these trends shape premiums, see Insurance coverage in the US.

Source note: This article includes information reported by ReinsuranceNe.

Live Poll

Do you expect your car insurance premiums to rise next year?