Judge Revives False Advertising Suit Against Baby Food Maker

A federal judge reversed an earlier dismissal, allowing a lawsuit over an organic avocado pouch's "Fruit & Veggie Blend" label to proceed.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Organic Food

Judge Revives False Advertising Suit Against Baby Food Maker

Live Poll

Do you trust packaged food labels to accurately describe what's inside?

U.S. District Judge Edward M. Chen reversed his earlier dismissal of a false advertising class action against Once Upon a Farm, a Berkeley, California baby food company. The suit, brought by Alexa Parashos, challenges the label on its "Wild Rumpus Avocado" organic pouch, which describes the product as an "Organic Fruit & Veggie Blend."

Why it matters

The ruling lets the case proceed on the theory that a "Fruit & Veggie Blend" label can mislead shoppers when the product contains no vegetables, a question that affects how packaged foods marketed to parents are labeled. Chen also denied Parashos' request to bar the company from marketing the product in the same way while the case continues.

The pouch's ingredients are pineapple, banana, apple, avocado and mint, and the FDA classifies avocado as a fruit and mint as an herb. The product is sold through Once Upon a Farm's children's line, which is carried in more than 22,000 stores nationwide.

The players

Once Upon a Farm

A Berkeley, California baby food company founded in 2011, which went public in February and is the defendant in the suit.

Edward M. Chen

A U.S. District Judge who initially dismissed the case and later reversed that decision after requesting additional briefing.

The details

Chen wrote that "Fruit & Veggie Blend" is not a "meaningless marketing term" that consumers would need more information to understand, and he found the misrepresentation claim viable under the Ninth Circuit's 2024 decision in Whiteside v. Kimberly Clark Corp. Chen had granted the company's motion to dismiss in early August, then changed course two weeks later and requested additional briefing before reversing on Monday.

Timeline

  1. 2025: Parashos sued Once Upon a Farm over the avocado pouch.

  2. February 2026: Once Upon a Farm went public.

  3. Early August 2026: Chen granted the company's motion to dismiss.

  4. Monday, November 16, 2026 (approx.): Chen reversed his dismissal, allowing the lawsuit to proceed.

Legal Context

Chen relied on the Ninth Circuit's 2024 Whiteside v. Kimberly Clark Corp. decision to find the misrepresentation claim viable. The ruling extends that appellate reasoning from consumer goods into the labeling of organic baby food.

Parents who buy packaged fruit and veggie blends may want to read ingredient lists closely, since the label alone may not reflect the actual produce in the pouch. The case could eventually influence how similar "blend" labels are written across the category.

The takeaway

Read the full ingredient list rather than relying on front-label phrases like "Fruit & Veggie Blend," since the terms may not describe what the product actually contains.

Further reading

Explore more coverage of Organic Food to see how labeling rules shape what shoppers buy.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Court House News Service.

Live Poll

Do you trust packaged food labels to accurately describe what's inside?