Hallmark Renews Hope Valley, Mistletoe Murders, When Calls the Heart

The network renewed three series and canceled Finding Mr. Christmas after two seasons.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Television

Flat-color editorial illustration of a wooden frontier-style house on a snowy rise beside a bare evergreen, evoking the cozy period holiday drama genre.
Hallmark renewed Hope Valley: 1874 for a second season, Mistletoe Murders for a third, and When Calls the Heart for Season 14, while canceling Finding Mr. Christmas after two seasons. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Hallmark renewed Hope Valley: 1874 for Season 2, Mistletoe Murders for a third season, and When Calls the Heart for Season 14, while canceling Finding Mr. Christmas after two seasons. The Hope Valley: 1874 debut was the most successful series launch on Hallmark+ to date.

Why it matters

The renewals extend several of the network's flagship holiday and period series, while the cancellation ends one of its holiday titles. Hope Valley: 1874 is a prequel to When Calls the Heart, linking the two franchises for viewers.

Hallmark's renewals rest on a debut for Hope Valley: 1874 that was the most successful series launch on Hallmark+ to date, a claim the network has made without a published viewership figure. Finding Mr. Christmas ended after two seasons, and no public ratings data for its cancellation decision was disclosed.

The players

Hallmark

Hallmark is a U.S. television network and streaming service known for its family-oriented holiday and romance programming.

Lori Loughlin

Lori Loughlin is an American actress known for her television work, who will appear in six episodes of When Calls the Heart Season 14.

Jonathan Bennett

Jonathan Bennett is an American actor who starred in Finding Mr. Christmas and has spoken publicly about the series' cancellation.

The details

Hallmark announced the Hope Valley: 1874 renewal on May 6, and Season 2 will air in 2027. Mistletoe Murders Season 3 airs Thursdays on the Hallmark Channel and streams on Hallmark+ the following day, while When Calls the Heart Season 14 was confirmed at the end of 2025.

Timeline

  1. May 6: Hallmark announces Hope Valley: 1874 renewal

  2. February: Mistletoe Murders Season 3 renewal reported

  3. End of 2025: When Calls the Heart Season 14 renewal confirmed

  4. January 2027: When Calls the Heart Season 14 premieres on the Hallmark Channel

Season Trajectory

Hope Valley: 1874 extends the When Calls the Heart universe backward in time, following the prequel model Hallmark has used to keep its flagship period franchise on the air. The renewal shows the network leaning on Hallmark+ launches to sustain its family-drama lineup.

Viewers can stream Season 1 of Hope Valley: 1874 on Hallmark+ now, and Mistletoe Murders Season 3 streams on the service the day after its Thursday Hallmark Channel airing. Access to Finding Mr. Christmas ends with its cancellation, so viewers will not see new episodes.

The takeaway

Renewal announcements often arrive months before premiere dates, so viewers who follow a series on Hallmark+ can plan viewing around scheduled airings. Checking the streaming schedule each week helps catch new episodes as soon as they become available.

What happens next

When Calls the Heart Season 14 premieres on the Hallmark Channel in January 2027, and Hope Valley: 1874 Season 2 premieres in 2027.

Further reading

Explore more Television coverage for context on how networks decide which series to renew.

Source note: This article includes information reported by EntertainmentNow.