Federal Circuit Invalidates Cocona Patent Over Indefiniteness

A precedential opinion affirms that Cocona Inc.'s US Patent No. 8,945,287 lacks clear measurement guidance for its moisture vapor transmission range.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Hiking

Flat gouache-painted editorial illustration of a taut woven fabric sheet with water droplets beading on one side, evoking a moisture-wicking material.
A federal appeals court on Tuesday invalidated Cocona Inc.'s US Patent No. 8,945,287, finding its moisture vapor transmission range too indefinite to enforce. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued a precedential opinion finding Cocona Inc.'s US Patent No. 8,945,287 indefinite and invalid, agreeing with a Colorado district judge's ruling. The patent describes a material that keeps water out of clothing without trapping sweat.

Why it matters

The ruling means the patent's claimed moisture vapor transmission range cannot be enforced as written because its measurement guidance is not clear enough. It also resolves the related infringement case in which Columbia Sportswear and The North Face prevailed against Cocona.

The ruling is a precedential Federal Circuit opinion on US Patent No. 8,945,287, which claims a moisture vapor transmission rate range that the court found lacks sufficiently clear measurement guidance. Whether Cocona will pursue further appeal has not been reported.

The players

Cocona Inc.

Cocona Inc. is a company that develops performance textile technologies, including moisture-management fabrics, and holds the patent at issue.

Columbia Sportswear

Columbia Sportswear is a Portland-based outdoor apparel company that competes in the performance outerwear market.

The North Face

The North Face is an outdoor apparel and equipment brand owned by VF Corporation and known for hiking and mountaineering gear.

The details

The patent requires covering materials within a certain moisture vapor transmission rate range, but the court found the patent lacks sufficiently clear guidance on how to measure that rate. The appeals court affirmed the Colorado district judge's finding that the patent is indefinite.

Timeline

  1. November 17, 2026: The Federal Circuit ruled the patent indefinite and invalid, and Columbia Sportswear and The North Face won their infringement case.

Legal Context

The decision applies the reasonable-certainty standard set by the Supreme Court in Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments (2014) to a numeric performance range in a fabric patent. Courts have increasingly scrutinized patents that define materials by measured properties without clear testing methods.

Hikers and buyers of moisture-managing outdoor clothing may see the patent-related disputes affect which products brands can market with the same technology. Buyers should check product specifications for independently tested moisture-management claims rather than relying on a patent name.

The takeaway

Patent claims that define materials by measurable properties must explain how those properties are measured, or they risk being struck down. For shoppers, performance claims are best judged by independent testing rather than by the existence of a patent.

Further reading

For more on outdoor gear and performance apparel, explore our Hiking coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.