Supreme Court Declines Oasis Tooling Chip Patent Appeal
The high court left in place rulings that invalidated two semiconductor patents held by Oasis Tooling Inc. as abstract under Section 101.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Semiconductors

The US Supreme Court declined to hear Oasis Tooling Inc.'s challenge to a decision in favor of Siemens Industry Software Inc. that invalidated US Patent Nos. 7,685,545 and 8,266,571. The rulings, issued by the district court in Delaware and the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, found the semiconductor patents ineligible for protection under Section 101 of the Patent Act.
Why it matters
The decision leaves in place rulings that treated an automated chip-design check as an abstract idea rather than a patentable invention. For the US semiconductor industry, it reinforces how courts are applying Section 101 eligibility standards to design-stage software tools.
The invalidated patents cover an automated check that confirms manufacturers use the most current versions of microscopic chip components before production, a task previously done manually. Both US Patent No. 7,685,545 and US Patent No. 8,266,571 were held ineligible under Section 101.
The players
Oasis Tooling Inc.
The company that held the two semiconductor patents and challenged their invalidation before the Supreme Court.
Siemens Industry Software Inc.
The software company that prevailed in the litigation, obtaining the decision that invalidated Oasis's patents.
The details
The claimed invention automated a manual task of analyzing chips at the design stage, which checks that manufacturers use the most updated versions of microscopic components before production. Courts found the claims abstract under Section 101 of the Patent Act, and the Supreme Court's decision not to take up Oasis Tooling's challenge leaves those findings intact.
Timeline
November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court declined to hear Oasis Tooling Inc.'s challenge.
Tech Race
The ruling extends Section 101 abstractness scrutiny to semiconductor design tools, the same kind of software-based chip engineering that chipmakers and EDA vendors rely on to compete. It shows that automating a previously manual chip-verification step does not by itself secure patent protection under current US law.
For engineers and companies building chip-design software, the ruling signals that automating a design-stage check may not be enough to obtain patent protection under Section 101. Developers in this space may need to weigh eligibility risks when deciding whether to seek patents or rely on other forms of protection.
The takeaway
Software that automates chip-engineering tasks faces a demanding patent eligibility bar, so companies should assess whether their innovations are defined in concrete technical terms rather than abstract functions. Documenting specific technical implementation details can matter as much as the functional benefit being claimed.
Further reading
Explore more Semiconductors coverage for context on chip industry developments.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.






