More Americans Shift Retirement Savings to Roth IRAs
Lawmakers are reviewing whether tax breaks for retirement accounts are too generous as Roth accounts gain popularity.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Retirement Planning

Live Poll
Should the government limit tax-free retirement accounts for the very wealthy?
58% of U.S. IRA holders had a Roth IRA in 2025, up from just over 50% in 2022. Roth accounts are funded with after-tax dollars, while traditional IRAs collect tax when money is withdrawn in retirement.
Why it matters
Lawmakers are taking a closer look at tax breaks for retirement savings as more people choose Roth accounts. The Joint Committee on Taxation estimated that tax breaks for IRAs and workplace retirement accounts reduced federal revenue by about $249.6 billion in 2025.
The share of IRA holders with a Roth IRA rose from just over 50% in 2022 to 58% in 2025, according to reported figures. Federal tax breaks for IRAs and workplace retirement accounts totaled about $249.6 billion in lost revenue in 2025, and the source does not address how that estimate may change under pending proposals.
The players
Joint Committee on Taxation
A nonpartisan congressional committee that provides official estimates of the revenue effects of tax legislation and existing tax provisions.
Ron Wyden
A long-serving U.S. senator from Oregon who chairs the Senate Finance Committee and has been a prominent voice on tax policy.
The details
Roth IRA contributions are made with money already taxed, so withdrawals in retirement are generally not taxed, while traditional IRA withdrawals are taxed when taken. A reported example involves a Roblox board member who held roughly 2 million company shares inside a Roth IRA before the company went public in 2021, when those shares were worth about $141 million. A proposal would require high-income Americans with retirement accounts above $10 million to take annual withdrawals regardless of age.
Timeline
2021: Roblox went public, and a board member's Roth IRA shares were valued at about $141 million at the debut.
2022: Roth IRAs made up just over 50% of IRA holdings.
2024: More than 1,000 people held IRAs worth at least $25 million.
2025: 58% of IRA holders had a Roth IRA, and retirement tax breaks cost about $249.6 billion in federal revenue.
July 2026: Senator Ron Wyden called the loophole egregious in a statement.
Market Dynamics
The rise of Roth IRAs follows the structure created by the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, which allowed tax-free qualified withdrawals in exchange for upfront taxation. As adoption climbs, the revenue cost of that design is now drawing congressional attention.
Savers choosing between Roth and traditional IRAs should weigh paying tax now against paying it later, since policy changes to high-balance accounts could affect planning. Households with large retirement balances may want to review how future withdrawal rules could apply to their accounts.
The takeaway
Roth accounts trade an upfront tax bill for tax-free withdrawals later, and that tradeoff is now under review. Savers should revisit their retirement mix as rules for high-balance accounts continue to be debated.
Further reading
For broader context, explore more Retirement Planning coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Benzinga.
Live Poll
Should the government limit tax-free retirement accounts for the very wealthy?










