Amazon Deals Study Disputed Over Savings Claims
A Groundwork Collaborative report says nearly one in three Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals offered no savings, which Amazon calls deeply flawed and false.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Couponing

Live Poll
Do you think waiting for Black Friday or Cyber Monday actually saves you money?
The Washington, D.C.-based think tank Groundwork Collaborative examined more than 350 Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals Amazon listed in 2024 and 2025 and found nearly one in three offered no actual savings. Amazon published a Nov. 16 statement calling the report deeply flawed and false.
Why it matters
Amazon accounts for more than one-third of U.S. e-commerce sales, so claims about whether its sale prices are genuine affect a large share of online shoppers. The dispute centers on how price history is measured, a question that determines whether a "deal" is truly a discount.
Groundwork Collaborative found nearly one in three of 350 Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals offered no savings, with 29% priced the same or lower in the month before the sale. Amazon counters that its own research found 98% of products sold at or below pre-sale prices, though it has not published that research.
The players
Amazon
Amazon is the American e-commerce and cloud computing company that reaps more than one-third of all U.S. e-commerce sales, according to Marketplace Pulse.
Groundwork Collaborative
Groundwork Collaborative is a Washington, D.C.-based progressive economic policy think tank that authored the report on Amazon's sale prices.
The details
Groundwork drew its 350 items from Amazon's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals pages and compared sale prices with earlier pricing. In a Nov. 13 letter, an Amazon executive wrote that Groundwork has limited interest in the facts, and Amazon said it strengthened its sales-event guardrails in 2026 so advertised deals almost always represent lower prices.
Timeline
2024: Start of the period when the examined Amazon deals were listed.
2025: Amazon ran a 12-day Black Friday sale and Cyber Week sales that generated $44 billion in online sales, per Adobe.
Nov. 13: An Amazon executive sent a letter to Groundwork's Owens disputing the report.
Nov. 16: Amazon published a statement on its website calling the report deeply flawed and false.
Market Landscape
Cyber Week delivered $44 billion in online sales in 2025, according to Adobe, and Amazon holds more than one-third of U.S. e-commerce sales. The Groundwork report tests whether that high-volume holiday spending is matched by genuine price reductions on the deals driving it.
Shoppers can check a product's price history before a Black Friday or Cyber Monday purchase to see whether the advertised discount is genuine. Comparing the sale price against prices from the prior few months helps identify deals that offer no real savings.
The takeaway
Holiday sale labels do not always reflect a real discount, so comparing current prices against a product's recent price history is the most reliable way to judge a deal. Shoppers who track prices over several months can avoid paying a premium for an advertised sale.
Further reading
Explore more on Couponing to see how to check whether a holiday sale price is genuinely lower.
Live Poll
Do you think waiting for Black Friday or Cyber Monday actually saves you money?









