Theologians Urge Bishops to Oppose Iran War
An open letter signed by 83 scholars asks U.S. Catholic bishops to publicly oppose the war on Iran ahead of their November assembly.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Catholicism

Live Poll
Should the U.S. cut military spending in the wake of the Iran war?
More than 80 theologians and educators issued an open letter dated Nov. 9 urging U.S. Catholic bishops to publicly oppose the U.S. war on Iran. The letter, spearheaded by Kevin Ahern of Manhattan University and Eli McCarthy of Georgetown University, has 83 signatories, including 77 U.S.-based scholars.
Why it matters
The letter asks bishops to use the Church's moral influence to press elected officials to prioritize diplomacy over military action. Signatories cited the grave suffering caused by the war and the wider conflict engulfing Palestine, Lebanon and Yemen.
The open letter carries 83 signatures, 77 from U.S.-based scholars and nine from international figures. The reported toll includes 23 U.S. troops killed and 865 wounded, and over 1,700 Iranian civilians killed, at least 254 of them children.
The players
Kevin Ahern
Kevin Ahern is a scholar at Manhattan University who spearheaded the open letter to U.S. bishops.
Eli McCarthy
Eli McCarthy is a scholar at Georgetown University who spearheaded the open letter to U.S. bishops.
Blase J. Cupich
Blase J. Cupich is the Cardinal Archbishop of Chicago who has spoken out against the war on Iran.
Robert W. McElroy
Robert W. McElroy is the Cardinal Archbishop of Washington who has spoken out against the war on Iran.
Joseph W. Tobin
Joseph W. Tobin is the Cardinal Archbishop of Newark who has spoken out against the war on Iran.
The details
The letter asks the bishops to take 10 specific steps. It was distributed as an open letter tied to the bishops' fall plenary assembly, and it highlights the Pentagon's estimate of the war's financial toll at over $47 billion. Cardinals Blase J. Cupich, Robert W. McElroy and Joseph W. Tobin have previously spoken out against the war.
Timeline
Feb. 28, 2026: The U.S. and Israel jointly launched the war on Iran.
Nov. 9, 2026: The open letter to U.S. bishops was issued.
Nov. 16-19, 2026: U.S. bishops hold their fall plenary assembly in Baltimore.
Roadmap
The letter asks bishops to revisit the moral framework on war and peace from the 1983 pastoral 'The Challenge of Peace.' It places the Iran war within a longer tradition of Catholic debate over when military force can be justified.
Catholics following the bishops' November meeting can track whether the assembly addresses the Iran war directly. Readers interested in the debate can review the letter's 10 requested steps as the plenary approaches.
The takeaway
The open letter shows how Catholic scholars are pressing the Church to apply its long-standing teaching on war and peace to the current conflict. Whether the bishops respond in Baltimore will indicate how the Church weighs that call.
What happens next
The U.S. bishops' fall plenary assembly is scheduled for Nov. 16-19 in Baltimore, where the letter's request may be taken up.
Further reading
Explore more on Catholicism coverage for the wider Church debate over war and peace.
Live Poll
Should the U.S. cut military spending in the wake of the Iran war?






