Judge Sends Ace Hardware Privacy Suit to Arbitration
A federal judge in California ruled that consumers' lawsuit over alleged website tracking must go to arbitration under the site's terms of use.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Retail

Live Poll
Do you trust companies to honor your choice to opt out of online tracking?
U.S. District Judge Edward Davila sent a privacy lawsuit against Ace Hardware to arbitration, ruling in a 13-page decision that the company gave website visitors reasonably conspicuous notice of its terms of use. Three consumers, Scott Pflaumer, Hans Cummings and Mark Rosenthal, had sued in March, alleging the company kept placing tracking tools on their devices after they tried to opt out.
Why it matters
The ruling shows how the design of a website's cookie banner can determine whether shoppers can take privacy disputes to court or must go to arbitration. It also underscores that opt-out controls and the terms attached to them can carry real legal consequences for consumers.
Judge Davila's ruling spans 13 pages and directs the parties to report back to the court within 10 days after arbitration is resolved. The core allegations about tracking after opt-out requests remain unadjudicated, and the case is now stayed pending arbitration.
The players
Ace Hardware
Ace Hardware is a cooperative hardware retailer whose franchised stores operate across the United States and abroad.
Edward Davila
Edward Davila is a U.S. District Judge serving in the Northern District of California, where he has presided over numerous civil and technology-related cases.
The details
The three plaintiffs alleged that Ace Hardware continued to place or access cookies and other tracking tools on their browsers after they attempted to reject unnecessary cookies. Ace Hardware moved to dismiss the suit or compel arbitration, arguing the complaint did not show a concrete injury warranting federal court review. The judge found that the cookie banner's 'terms of use' link, displayed in bold, underlined bright blue type, and the statement that continuing to browse constituted acceptance, gave reasonably conspicuous notice of the arbitration clause.
Timeline
March: Plaintiffs filed the lawsuit against Ace Hardware.
This week (November 2026): Judge Edward Davila ruled the dispute must go to arbitration and stayed proceedings.
Within 10 days of arbitration resolution: The parties must report back to the court.
Market Landscape
The ruling reflects a broader pattern in which courts are weighing whether website cookie banners give adequate notice of terms that restrict consumers' legal options. Retailers increasingly pair privacy notices with arbitration clauses, shaping how privacy claims can be pursued across the online shopping industry.
Shoppers who opt out of cookies on retail websites may still be bound by terms of use they never read, and those terms can send disputes into private arbitration. Consumers should review the terms linked from a site's cookie banner before deciding how to proceed.
The takeaway
Clear disclosure controls how privacy disputes are resolved, so consumers should read terms linked from cookie banners before assuming an opt-out protects their data.
What happens next
The parties must report back to the court within 10 days after the arbitration is resolved, and the case remains stayed until then.
Further reading
For more on how retailers handle online shopper data, see Retail.
Source note: This article includes information reported by MediaPost.
Live Poll
Do you trust companies to honor your choice to opt out of online tracking?










