Horror Film Other Mommy Received Low Ratings
The film adaptation of the novel Incidents Around the House struggled to impress critics.
Updated on Oct. 10, 2026 in Horror
Live Poll
Do you typically avoid seeing new movies in theaters if they receive poor early reviews?
Directed by Rob Savage and starring Jessica Chastain, the horror film Other Mommy arrived in theaters this weekend to poor critical reception. The movie, which is based on the novel Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman, currently holds a 17% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
Why it matters
The low critical scores suggest the film failed to meet audience expectations for the horror genre. Critics have specifically cited issues with the film's editing and its inability to effectively generate scares.
The film Other Mommy currently holds a 17% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and received a 4/10 score from ScreenRant. The production has a total runtime of 93 minutes.
The players
Rob Savage
He is the director of the horror film Other Mommy.
Jessica Chastain
She is an Academy Award-winning actress who stars in the lead role of the film.
Josh Malerman
He is the author of the novel Incidents Around the House, which serves as the basis for the movie.
The details
Reviewers have criticized the movie as being uninspired and dumb, noting that it suffers from choppy editing throughout. Despite the involvement of star Jessica Chastain, the project has struggled to resonate with critics upon its theatrical debut.
Timeline
Josh Malerman published the source novel, Incidents Around the House, in 2024.
Other Mommy was released on October 9, 2026.
The film arrived in theaters for the weekend on October 10-11, 2026.
Industry Dynamics
This release highlights the ongoing challenge for Hollywood studios to successfully adapt contemporary horror novels into hit films. While high-profile casting can generate initial buzz, poor critical consensus often complicates a movie's ability to gain momentum in a crowded theatrical market.
Viewers can currently watch Other Mommy in theaters nationwide following its October release. Those interested in the source material can read the original novel to compare the narrative before deciding on a theatrical ticket purchase.
The takeaway
When choosing a film to watch this weekend, readers may want to look beyond star power and consider aggregated critical reviews. Checking ratings can help determine if a high-profile horror project will deliver a quality scare or fall short of its genre potential.
Further reading
For more coverage on upcoming and recent scary movies, explore the Horror section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Collider.
Live Poll
Do you typically avoid seeing new movies in theaters if they receive poor early reviews?
