Prediction Markets Have Diverted Sportsbook Bettors

New data reveals that prediction platforms are successfully drawing wagers away from traditional state-licensed sportsbooks.

Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Gambling

Bold vector editorial illustration showing a set of gold coin scales balanced against a digital wireframe cube.
New survey data shows that prediction markets have captured 35% of the sports betting market by operating as federally regulated commodities. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Are you more likely to use digital prediction platforms than traditional sportsbooks for your betting?

Prediction markets have captured significant market share from traditional sportsbooks by operating as federally regulated commodities rather than state-licensed gambling ventures. A September 2026 survey found that 35% of bettors now use traditional platforms less frequently because of these alternative exchanges.

Why it matters

By classifying sports outcome contracts as commodities futures, prediction markets avoid state-level gambling taxes and licensing requirements. This regulatory divergence has sparked legal conflicts, as states seek to recapture revenue lost to these federally overseen platforms.

In 2025, Americans placed $166.94 billion in legal sports wagers, resulting in $3.71 billion in state tax revenue. The American Gaming Association estimates that prediction markets have diverted over $500 million in potential state tax income.

The players

Kalshi

This prediction market platform is currently litigating against Illinois to defend its status as a federally regulated commodities exchange.

Commodity Futures Trading Commission

This federal agency holds oversight responsibility for prediction markets, classifying their sports outcome contracts as commodities futures.

American Gaming Association

This national trade association represents the interests of the U.S. casino gaming industry and tracks industry revenue data.

The details

Bettors are increasingly migrating to prediction markets, with 77% of users citing superior digital user experience as their primary reason for switching platforms. Kalshi is currently challenging Illinois in court over the state's attempt to impose a 15% tax on these federally overseen contracts.

Timeline

  1. 2006: Congress passed the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act.

  2. 2015: The New York attorney general ordered daily fantasy platforms to cease operations.

  3. 2025: Americans legally wagered $166.94 billion on sports events.

  4. September 2026: Fullstory surveyed over 1,000 U.S. consumers regarding their betting habits.

Culture Shift

The emergence of prediction markets mirrors the historical transition of daily fantasy sports, where companies leveraged specific legal definitions to bypass state-level gambling restrictions. This ongoing shift reflects a broader consumer migration toward digital platforms that prioritize streamlined user experiences over traditional state-regulated interfaces.

Bettors may find their preferred platforms restricted or subject to new state-level fee structures as governments intensify their efforts to tax prediction markets. Users should monitor whether their chosen exchange remains legal in their state as regional authorities challenge federal oversight.

The takeaway

Prediction markets are fundamentally changing the betting landscape by offering an alternative to traditional, highly taxed state sportsbooks. Consumers should expect continued legal friction between states and federal regulators as the market for outcome-based contracts matures.

Further reading

For more on the evolving regulatory environment for online gaming, visit the Gambling section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Fortune.

Live Poll

Are you more likely to use digital prediction platforms than traditional sportsbooks for your betting?