Judge Dismissed Class Action Against United Wholesale Mortgage

A federal court ruled the company did not violate the Employee Retirement Income Security Act in its 401(k) management.

Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Retirement Planning

Bold flat-color editorial illustration showing a brass key on gold-colored ingots, representing institutional fiduciary policy and legal clarity.
A U.S. District Court judge dismissed a class action lawsuit against United Wholesale Mortgage regarding the company's 401(k) retirement plan management. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust your employer to manage your retirement savings plan in your best interest?

U.S. District Judge Susan K. DeClercq has dismissed a class action lawsuit alleging United Wholesale Mortgage mismanaged its employee retirement plan. The suit claimed the company's use of unvested employer contributions to pay for future benefits cost workers over $1.8 million.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that discretionary plan choices, such as using forfeiture proceeds, do not necessarily constitute fiduciary breaches under federal law. This decision provides guidance for companies navigating how they handle unvested funds within retirement plans.

The 401(k) plan served over 7,000 participants and held more than $149 million in assets at the end of 2023. In 2025, United Wholesale Mortgage contributed $8 million in employee matching funds, up from $6.4 million in 2024.

The players

United Wholesale Mortgage

This is a major mortgage lending company that provides home financing services to individuals across the United States.

Susan K. DeClercq

She is the U.S. District Judge who presided over the class action lawsuit and issued the final ruling.

The details

Plaintiffs argued that the company unfairly used unvested employer contributions to cover future obligations rather than using them to reduce plan expenses. The court found that plan language did not mandate the use of forfeiture proceeds for administrative costs and that ERISA does not characterize such choices as breaches.

Timeline

  1. 2018: Onity and Wells Fargo ERISA litigation was initially filed.

  2. 2023: The 401(k) plan recorded over 7,000 participants and $149 million in assets.

  3. 2024: United Wholesale Mortgage provided $6.4 million in employee contribution matching.

  4. 2025: United Wholesale Mortgage provided $8 million in employee contribution matching.

  5. September 2026: Judge DeClercq issued the ruling to dismiss the lawsuit.

Market Dynamics

This case reflects the ongoing scrutiny of corporate retirement plan administration under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. The decision reinforces judicial trends regarding how employers may manage discretionary forfeiture proceeds within their benefit structures.

For employees participating in company-sponsored 401(k) plans, the ruling clarifies that specific employer strategies for unvested funds are legally permissible if they align with plan documents. Participants should review their specific Summary Plan Description to understand how their employer handles forfeitures.

The takeaway

Employees should regularly review the summary plan documents provided by their HR department to understand how contributions and forfeitures are managed. This case highlights how critical specific plan language is when determining the legality of employer actions regarding retirement assets.

Further reading

Learn more about the complexities of benefit administration in the Retirement Planning section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by National Mortgage News.

Live Poll

Do you trust your employer to manage your retirement savings plan in your best interest?