Derailment Caused by Shattered Railcar Wheel Rim

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada has released its investigation into a February 2025 CN freight train derailment near Emo, Ontario.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Business

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a cracked steel railway wheel resting on gravel beside steel rails, evoking a rail safety failure.
A Canadian National freight train carrying fertilizer derailed near Emo, Ontario, on February 4, 2025, after a shattered railcar wheel rim caused the 14-car derailment, the Transportation Safety Board of Canada found. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think railways are replacing older, risky equipment fast enough?

A Canadian National Railway freight train carrying fertilizer derailed near Emo, Ontario, on February 4, 2025, with 14 loaded hopper cars leaving the tracks. No dangerous goods were involved and no injuries were reported.

Why it matters

The Transportation Safety Board found the derailment was caused by imperfections in a railcar wheel that resulted in a shattered rim failure. The investigation highlights an ongoing safety question about older wheels that remain in service across Canadian rail networks.

The TSB's findings cover 14 prior broken-rim derailments from 2003 to 2025, with eight involving wheels made before the AAR steel cleanliness standard. Estimated annual costs of shattered rims to railways are put at $50 million, though how many older wheels remain in service is still unknown.

The players

Canadian National Railway

Canadian National Railway is one of Canada's largest freight railways, operating a network spanning the country from the Atlantic to the Pacific coasts.

Transportation Safety Board of Canada

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada is an independent federal agency that investigates marine, pipeline, rail and aviation transportation occurrences to advance transportation safety.

Transport Canada

Transport Canada is the federal department responsible for regulating and overseeing transportation policy, safety and compliance across Canada.

The details

The 14 loaded hopper cars carrying fertilizer were travelling west from Fort Frances to Winnipeg when they derailed. Transport Canada issued CN a letter of non-compliance on February 28, 2025, citing a lack of documentation confirming a freight car inspection before the train entered Canada at Fort Frances.

Timeline

  1. February 4, 2025: CN freight train derails near Emo, Ontario.

  2. February 28, 2025: Transport Canada issues non-compliance letter to CN.

  3. 2003 to 2025: TSB investigates 14 other broken-rim derailments.

  4. November 18, 2026: TSB releases investigation results on the Emo derailment.

Market Landscape

The Emo derailment is the latest in a documented series of broken-rim failures the TSB tracked from 2003 to 2025, with eight of 14 prior cases involving wheels made before the AAR steel cleanliness standard. The pattern points to the rail industry's reliance on older wheels still in service, a question that bears on the competitive and operational planning of freight carriers across North America.

Freight shipments of fertilizer and other goods along rail corridors in Ontario and Manitoba depend on wheel safety standards that remain under review. The TSB's findings point to older wheels still in service, which may affect rail reliability for customers who ship by train.

The takeaway

The investigation shows that older railcar wheels can fail in ways that cause derailments even when no dangerous goods are involved. Tracking which pre-2003 wheels remain in service is a concrete step regulators and carriers can take to reduce that risk.

Further reading

For more on the rail safety issues behind this story, see the Transportation section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CBC News.

Live Poll

Do you think railways are replacing older, risky equipment fast enough?