Federal Court Quashes Human Rights Commission Decision
The court sent an employee's complaint back to the Canadian Human Rights Commission for reconsideration and awarded him $2,500 in costs.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Human Resources

The Federal Court found a Canadian Human Rights Commission decision unreasonable and returned the matter to the commission for reconsideration. The court also awarded the applicant $2,500 in costs.
Why it matters
The ruling sends the complaint back to the commission rather than leaving the earlier decision in place, so the matter will be reviewed again. The case also shows how a union grievance and a human rights complaint can run side by side, and how advice on which process to pursue can affect a complaint.
The Federal Court awarded the applicant $2,500 in costs after finding the commission's decision unreasonable. The grievances were commenced on December 14, 2017, and the source does not indicate how the commission will rule on reconsideration.
The players
Canadian Human Rights Commission
The federal agency that receives and investigates human rights complaints under Canadian federal law, and whose decision in this case was found unreasonable by the Federal Court.
The details
The applicant sought judicial review to set aside a Canadian Human Rights Commission decision, asserting that his paralegal failed to advise him about a mandamus order, the risk of the commission refusing his complaint for non-exhaustion of the grievance process, and the need to re-engage that process when a hearing date was set. The Federal Court found the commission's decision unreasonable and returned the matter for reconsideration.
Timeline
December 14, 2017: Union commenced two grievances on the applicant's behalf.
March 2022: The applicant hired a licensed paralegal, who suggested he withdraw from the grievance process.
August 7: Federal Court of Appeal confirmed there was no active BCMEA-ILWU collective agreement.
Legal Context
The case turns on how the Canadian Human Rights Commission treats complaints that run alongside a union grievance, a question the Federal Court has now sent back to the commission for reconsideration. The court's finding that the earlier decision was unreasonable places this ruling within the body of judicial review of commission decisions.
Employees who file a human rights complaint while also pursuing a union grievance may need to understand how the two processes interact before deciding which to continue. The ruling shows that advice on withdrawing from a grievance can have consequences for whether a complaint is heard.
The takeaway
Employees weighing a human rights complaint against a union grievance should confirm how each process affects the other before withdrawing from either. Advice to drop one process can affect whether the complaint is later accepted.
Further reading
For related coverage of workplace complaints and employee rights, see Human Resources in Canada.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Canadian Lawyer Magazine.






