Ottawa Won't Appeal Maternity Leave EI Ruling

The federal government will not challenge a Federal Court of Appeal decision that found contested Employment Insurance provisions violated the Charter.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Women’s Issues

Ottawa Won't Appeal Maternity Leave EI Ruling

Live Poll

Do you think the federal government should do more to support working parents through employment insurance?

Employment and Social Development Canada confirmed it will not appeal the Federal Court of Appeal's September ruling that certain Employment Insurance Act provisions violated the Charter of Rights. The case concerns women who lose their jobs during or shortly after maternity leave and cannot receive regular EI benefits in full or in part.

Why it matters

Affected women did not accumulate enough insurable hours while on maternity leave, leaving them without full or partial benefits when they lose work. The decision leaves the contested provisions open to reform across Canada.

The Federal Court of Appeal ruled in September that the contested provisions violated the Charter of Rights. Six mothers have fought since 2018, and the government has not stated the number of other women affected.

The players

Employment and Social Development Canada

The federal department responsible for administering Employment Insurance and social programs across Canada.

Patty Hajdu

Canada's federal minister overseeing Employment and Social Development Canada, responsible for the government's social program policy.

The details

Employment and Social Development Canada confirmed the decision on Tuesday when contacted. The Montreal Unemployment Action Movement supported the six mothers in the case and hopes it will lead to a thorough review of the Employment Insurance Act.

Timeline

  1. September: Federal Court of Appeal ruled the provisions violated the Charter.

  2. 2018: Six mothers began fighting to change the law.

  3. Tuesday, November 10, 2026: Government confirmed it would not appeal the ruling.

  4. Over the next year: Government to work on solutions to improve the Employment Insurance system.

Legal Context

The ruling tests whether the Employment Insurance Act's insurable-hours rules comply with the Charter when applied to women returning from maternity leave. The government's decision not to appeal leaves the Federal Court of Appeal's finding standing as a precedent.

Women who lose jobs during or shortly after maternity leave may be eligible for EI benefits if the reforms proceed. Those currently affected should check their insurable-hours status with Employment and Social Development Canada.

The takeaway

A court ruling against federal EI rules shows that insurable-hours requirements can be challenged under the Charter, and affected workers should track the government's promised system review.

What happens next

Over the next year, the Government of Canada will work on solutions to improve the Employment Insurance system.

Further reading

For more on related policy debates, see Women's Issues coverage across Canada.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CTVNews.

Live Poll

Do you think the federal government should do more to support working parents through employment insurance?