Chatbots Give Flawed Retirement Advice, Study Finds
The Actuaries Institute found four popular chatbots gave potentially incomplete or inappropriate responses to Australian retirement and investment scenarios.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Financial Planning

Live Poll
Would you trust an AI chatbot for retirement advice?
The Actuaries Institute released a discussion paper finding that four popular chatbots gave potentially incomplete or inappropriate retirement and investment advice. Most responses tested were judged potentially incomplete or inappropriate, and all four failed a detailed query about retirement advice.
Why it matters
Most people lack the financial experience and expertise to ask chatbots the right questions in the right way, raising risks for Australians seeking retirement guidance from AI tools. The paper argues that trusted AI-enabled financial advice will depend on lifting consumer literacy, giving providers room to innovate, and strengthening regulation and supervision.
The research tested four chatbots using five hypothetical Australian retirement and investment scenarios, and most responses were potentially incomplete or inappropriate. One in eight over-45s reportedly use AI for super and retirement questions, but the paper leaves open who is liable when AI-generated financial advice is wrong.
The players
Actuaries Institute
The Actuaries Institute is the professional body for actuaries in Australia, which published the discussion paper examining AI-generated financial advice.
The details
The discussion paper, titled 'How AI can help people make better financial decisions: Improving access to financial help, guidance and advice,' found chatbots and AI-enabled advice models struggled with calculations, projections and scenario modelling. Chatbots generated recommendations that appear to be personal advice even when disclaimers were included.
Timeline
16 November 2026: Actuaries Institute published the discussion paper on chatbot financial advice.
Planning Ahead
The Actuaries Institute's discussion paper sets out four areas for action, including raising financial and AI literacy and updating regulations and enforcement. It frames the current gap between chatbot outputs and reliable retirement guidance as a problem that regulators and providers must address together.
Readers using chatbots for super or retirement questions should verify calculations and projections with a licensed adviser before acting. Most people may not know how to frame questions to get complete answers from these tools.
The takeaway
Treat chatbot retirement answers as a starting point rather than personal advice, and check any projections or calculations with a qualified professional. Clear questions and independent verification remain the safest approach.
Further reading
Explore more on Financial Planning to see how retirement decisions are approached in practice.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Financial Standard.
Live Poll
Would you trust an AI chatbot for retirement advice?










