Critics Accused Major AI Labs of Cartel Behavior

Prominent voices claim that leading developers are using safety rhetoric to stifle competition and control governance.

Updated on Sept. 24, 2026 in Artificial Intelligence

Bold flat-color editorial illustration depicting a steel lock beside a silicon wafer, representing industry competition and governance constraints.
Prominent AI experts have accused leading laboratories of forming a cartel, alleging that safety rhetoric is being used to stifle competition and consolidate industry control. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should the government prevent major AI companies from setting their own global safety standards?

Father Paolo Benanti, the Vatican's top AI adviser, has accused major artificial intelligence laboratories of forming a cartel to consolidate control. Aidan Gomez has similarly argued that companies like OpenAI and Anthropic leverage safety standards to prevent outside firms from competing.

Why it matters

Critics suggest that these AI giants use existential superintelligence risks as a shield to exclude newcomers from governance processes and protect incumbents from public competition.

Compliance with proposed testing and incident reporting rules is projected to increase overhead costs for smaller laboratories. This structure relies on three companies central to the current governance debate.

The players

Father Paolo Benanti

He serves as a primary artificial intelligence adviser to the Vatican.

Aidan Gomez

He is the founder of Cohere and a vocal critic of current AI industry governance.

Sam Altman

He is the chief executive officer of OpenAI.

Dario Amodei

He serves as the chief executive officer of Anthropic.

Michael Kratsios

He is a former U.S. technology official who has opposed expanded global AI governance.

The details

Legislators Josh Hawley and Ted Cruz successfully removed an antitrust exemption for AI companies from the NDAA manager's package, signaling a shift in federal oversight. This follows broader skepticism from figures like Michael Kratsios, who rejected new global governance structures for the industry.

Timeline

  1. September 13, 2026: Aidan Gomez published an essay criticizing industry standards bodies.

  2. September 23, 2026: Sam Altman and Dario Amodei briefed the UN Security Council.

  3. September 2026: Father Paolo Benanti accused major labs of operating as a cartel.

The Tech Race

The 1975 SEC designation of specific credit rating agencies serves as a historical parallel for how regulatory standards can unintentionally consolidate industry power. This current conflict highlights a potential transition from open innovation toward a restricted, highly regulated model.

Users may see fewer diverse AI tools as smaller competitors struggle with the high costs of mandated safety reporting and compliance. This consolidation could ultimately limit the variety of software applications available to consumers.

The takeaway

The ongoing debate over AI governance underscores the tension between necessary safety measures and the preservation of a competitive marketplace. Readers should watch how upcoming legislative shifts in the United States impact the ability of smaller startups to enter the AI sector.

Further reading

For more on the current state of governance, visit the Artificial Intelligence section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Startup Fortune.

Live Poll

Should the government prevent major AI companies from setting their own global safety standards?