Labour Court Strikes Off Numsa Leave to Appeal

The court ruled the appeal was not properly before it because attorneys failed to provide proof of mandate.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Unions

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single steel gate standing alone across an open highveld plain, evoking a barrier to participation.
The Labour Court struck off Numsa's application for leave to appeal on Tuesday, leaving its October 22 judgment blocking national leaders from excluding Mpumalanga regional delegates. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Labour Court struck off an application by the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa) for leave to appeal in a leadership dispute involving its Mpumalanga region. The ruling followed an October 22 judgment preventing national leadership from excluding Mpumalanga regional delegates from meetings.

Why it matters

The dispute centres on whether the union's national leadership may restrict regional delegates' participation and voting rights, a question that goes to how Numsa's constitution is applied. The ruling leaves the October judgment in place for now, shaping how the Mpumalanga region can take part in the union's governance.

The Labour Court's October 22 judgment barred national leadership from excluding Mpumalanga regional delegates from meetings. Numsa's Central Committee resolved on October 23 that the February 2025 litigation mandate covered only the Road Accident Fund and that the union would abide by the October judgment.

The players

National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa)

Numsa is one of South Africa's largest trade unions, representing metalworkers across the country and playing a prominent role in the labour movement.

Irvin Jim

Irvin Jim is the long-serving general secretary of Numsa and a prominent figure in South African labour politics.

Labour Court of South Africa

The Labour Court is the specialist South African court that hears disputes arising from labour relations, including union governance matters.

The details

Numsa's Central Committee halted its meeting pending the appeal, but regional leaders continued it and resolved to suspend the national office bearers and appoint a task coordination team. A special National Executive Committee officially suspended the national office bearers, and Irvin Jim suspended several regional leaders. Makhanya disputed the authority of a Pretoria law firm and its correspondent attorneys to act for the union, and the court noted that the challenge received no response or proof of authority.

Timeline

  1. February 2025: The resolution relied on by national office bearers for a litigation mandate was adopted.

  2. 22 October: The Labour Court judgment barring exclusion of Mpumalanga delegates was handed down.

  3. 23 October: The Central Committee resolved that the mandate was limited to the Road Accident Fund.

  4. 16 November 2026: The Labour Court struck off Numsa's application for leave to appeal.

Legal Context

The ruling builds on the October 22 Labour Court judgment, which restrained national leadership from excluding Mpumalanga delegates. Because the appeal failed on the proof-of-mandate defect rather than the merits, that earlier order continues to govern the union's internal dispute.

Mpumalanga delegates remain entitled to attend Numsa meetings under the October 22 judgment while the union's internal dispute continues. Union members in the region should expect continued uncertainty over who represents them until the leadership question is resolved.

The takeaway

Internal union disputes can turn on procedural details such as proof of attorney mandate, so the outcome of a case may depend as much on process as on substance. Members who want to follow governance decisions should track official union communications and court records.

Further reading

For more on how labour disputes like this unfold, explore our Unions coverage.