Court Orders Return of R750,000 Jaguar

A Free State high court ruled that a professional rugby player must return a Jaguar XF to his older brother.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Car Types

Dark grey luxury sedan parked alone on a dry dirt track across open golden grassland under a wide warm sky.
A Free State high court ordered professional rugby player Mzwanele Zito to return a Jaguar XF valued above R750,000 to his brother Andile. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you trust a family member's verbal promise about who owns a valuable item?

The Free State high court ordered professional rugby player Mzwanele Richman Zito to return a Jaguar XF valued at more than R750,000 to his brother, the court's acting judge R Sepato ruling that the car must be handed back immediately. The judgment also ordered Mzwanele to sign documents transferring the registration back and to pay legal costs, including counsel's fees.

Why it matters

The court found Mzwanele's claim that the car was a gift inconsistent, unreliable and riddled with contradictions, and held that the registration certificate in his name did not on its own prove ownership. The ruling underlines that vehicle registration records alone may not settle who owns a car.

The Jaguar XF was valued at more than R750,000 when it was acquired, and the court has ordered its immediate return. Whether the judgment will be appealed has not been reported.

The players

Mzwanele Richman Zito

A professional rugby player who was ordered by the Free State high court to return the Jaguar XF to his brother.

Free State High Court

The South African high court division that issued the ruling and ordered the car's return and the payment of legal costs.

The details

Andile had bought the Jaguar and kept the original registration certificate and spare keys, and had made the car available to Mzwanele for use in 2021. The brothers changed the registration into Mzwanele's name on 28 September 2023, which Andile said was to avoid traffic fines issued in Mzwanele's name, while Mzwanele argued the car was a gift partly meant to make up for Andile selling a Golf 7 he considered his.

Timeline

  1. 2021: Andile made the Jaguar available to Mzwanele for his use.

  2. 28 September 2023: The brothers changed the vehicle registration into Mzwanele's name.

  3. Last week: The ownership dispute was decided in the Free State high court.

Roadmap

The ruling follows the South African courts' general approach of looking beyond registration papers to the substance of who paid for and controls a vehicle. It shows how informal family arrangements over expensive cars can end up in formal litigation.

Anyone who has lent a car to a family member or registered a vehicle in someone else's name may find the ruling relevant. The case suggests that registration papers alone may not protect an owner in a dispute.

The takeaway

Keep written proof of purchase, original documents and clear records of any gift or loan of a vehicle. A registration certificate alone may not settle who owns a car if a dispute reaches court.

Further reading

Explore more on Car Types to see how different vehicle models are classified and compared.

Live Poll

Would you trust a family member's verbal promise about who owns a valuable item?