Court Weighs Three-Year Wait for Attorneys

The Constitutional Court is hearing a challenge to the three-year period newly admitted attorneys must serve before appearing in superior courts.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stately civic courthouse facade with broad steps in deep navy and cream, evoking the institutional weight of a constitutional court challenge.
South Africa's Constitutional Court heard a challenge Tuesday to the Legal Practice Act's three-year wait before newly admitted attorneys may appear in the High Court, Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should newly admitted attorneys be allowed to appear in higher courts immediately?

South Africa's Constitutional Court heard a challenge to the Legal Practice Act's three-year waiting period before newly admitted attorneys may appear in the High Court, Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court. The Pretoria High Court previously declared the requirement unconstitutional, and the apex court must now decide whether to confirm that ruling.

Why it matters

The requirement currently pushes newly admitted attorneys to build their practices around magistrates' and regional courts while they wait to qualify for superior court appearances. The outcome will determine whether attorneys and advocates are treated differently under the law.

The Legal Practice Act sets a three-year period before attorneys may appear in the High Court, Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court. The Constitutional Court has yet to rule on whether the Pretoria High Court's finding that this requirement is unconstitutional will stand.

The players

Constitutional Court

South Africa's apex court, which holds final authority on constitutional matters and must decide whether to confirm the Pretoria High Court's ruling.

Legal Practice Act

South African legislation governing the legal profession, including the rights of appearance attorneys hold in superior courts.

The details

Applicant Kgomotso Ramalepe, represented by attorney Mabulenyana Marweshe, challenges section 25 of the Legal Practice Act. Chief Justice Mandisa Maya and other justices pressed the applicant on whether attorneys and advocates can be compared, while the applicant argued the three-year period does not necessarily ensure the experience needed for superior courts.

Timeline

  1. 19 November 2026: Constitutional Court hearing on the three-year waiting period challenge

Legal Context

The challenge tests section 25 of the Legal Practice Act, a provision the Pretoria High Court has already found unconstitutional for unfairly discriminating against attorneys compared with advocates. The Constitutional Court's decision will determine whether that finding stands and how rights of appearance are structured for newly admitted attorneys in South Africa.

Newly admitted attorneys currently cannot appear in superior courts until they complete three years of practice, which limits them to magistrates' and regional courts in the meantime. A Constitutional Court ruling confirming the Pretoria High Court's decision would remove that restriction for attorneys.

The takeaway

The three-year rule is being tested against the principle that attorneys and advocates should not be treated unequally without justification. The Constitutional Court's ruling will shape how South Africa structures entry into its highest courts for the legal profession.

Further reading

For more on the courts shaping this debate, see Law coverage across South Africa.

Source note: This article includes information reported by EWN Traffic.

Live Poll

Should newly admitted attorneys be allowed to appear in higher courts immediately?